The 2026-10-18 live test on the dev rig showed the opt-in managed ack path
cannot work as built: AlarmClient.RegisterConsumer returns -65 alongside the
worker's wnwrap reader (the worker then silently falls back to wnwrap), the
managed client does not recognise the wnwrap GUID even standalone, and the
gateway's GUID arm sends empty identity fields. Replace the docs' claim that
the path works with the measured results and tell operators to leave
MXGATEWAY_USE_MANAGED_ALARM_ACK unset.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Review fixes for the opt-in managed GUID ack:
- Subtag-mode GUID acks (forced subtag, or failover on the standby) stay on
the consumer; their GUIDs are synthetic and only the subtag consumer can
resolve them. Forced-subtag sessions no longer build a managed client.
- A failed managed Initialize/Register/Subscribe drops back to the wnwrap
ack path instead of failing the alarm subscription.
- Drop stale crefs to a nonexistent Unverified member in
WnalNativeAckConsumer.
- Unit tests for routing, fallback, and disposal; document
MXGATEWAY_USE_MANAGED_ALARM_ACK.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds a managed acknowledge path over AVEVA's modern alarm client so GUID
acks carry full operator identity (domain + full name) and work on builds
where the wnwrap COM AlarmAckByGUID is E_NOTIMPL. Default off; opt in with
MXGATEWAY_USE_MANAGED_ALARM_ACK=1 (wnwrap behavior unchanged otherwise).
- AaManagedAlarmAckConsumer: reflection wrapper over
aaAlarmManagedClient.AlarmClient (InitializeConsumer/RegisterConsumer/
Subscribe/AlarmAckByGUID); EnvGatedFactory degrades to null (wnwrap) if the
DLL can't load, so alarm reads never break.
- IManagedAlarmAckClient seam. AlarmDispatcher takes an optional client and
routes GUID acks to it (subscribing + disposing it alongside the reader).
- AlarmCommandHandler gains an optional managedAckFactory; WorkerPipeSession
wires AaManagedAlarmAckConsumer.EnvGatedFactory at the production sites.
- WnalNativeAckConsumer: confirmed native alarmlst.dll WNAL submit layer
(WNALalarmReqSetText / WNALUserRequest / WNALUserRequestEx + lpAlmAck
layout). List acquisition is intentionally not hand-rolled: the alarm-record
layout and selection semantics are provider-defined and not recoverable from
alarmlst.dll, so inferring them risks acking the wrong alarm.
- AlarmManagedGuidAckLiveSmokeTests: skip-gated live smoke that pulls a real
(non-degraded) alarm GUID and asserts the ack APPLIES (Acknowledge
transition / acked snapshot), not merely rc=0.
By-name acks stay on wnwrap (AlarmClient has no AlarmAckByName). Grounded in
static RE of alarmlst.dll, aaAlarmManagedClient.dll and alarmmgr.exe.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Tracking IDs are review bookkeeping that rots in shipped source; the rationale they tagged is kept. Comment-only change (CommentChecker 458 -> 16 false positives).
Bumps ZB.MOM.WW.Auth.Abstractions, .ApiKeys, .AspNetCore, and .Ldap in
ZB.MOM.WW.MxGateway.Server.csproj and ZB.MOM.WW.MxGateway.IntegrationTests.csproj.
0.3.0 is additive (new IApiKeyStoreMigrator, SqliteAuthStoreMigrator implements it,
old ctors retained) — no source changes needed. Restore, Release build (0 warnings/
0 errors), and dotnet test on the NonWindows solution are unchanged versus the
pre-bump baseline: 1198 passed, 0 failed, 19 skipped (live-only tests, opt-in via
env vars).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Wzg6NUCWHipSexLs2cgRFv
The subtag fallback's coverage was fixed at SubscribeAlarms time and never
re-examined. AlarmWatchListResolver deliberately swallows a Galaxy Repository
outage and returns whatever configuration contributed, so a discovery failure at
startup left the monitor subscribed with an empty watch-list for the rest of its
life. In Auto mode the alarmmgr primary keeps working, so nothing looks wrong
until the failover that needs the standby finds it covering zero alarms — with a
single LogWarning emitted possibly weeks earlier as the only evidence.
ResolveAsync now returns an AlarmWatchListResolution (targets + whether discovery
was attempted and whether it failed, with the failure message), which is what the
caller needed to tell "discovery produced nothing" from "nothing was configured".
GatewayAlarmMonitor grades that resolution against the effective mode and folds
the verdict into AlarmProviderStatus, so it reaches the feed, the dashboard badge
and every late-joining subscriber:
- zero targets while the mode can need them (Auto/ForceSubtag) -> degraded with
SubtagWatchListEmpty; discovery enabled but failing adds SubtagDiscoveryFailed
and the message. ForceAlarmManager builds no subtag consumer and is not graded.
- degraded is now the OR of "subtag is serving" and "the watch-list covers
nothing", so the Auto case where alarmmgr is healthy and the standby is empty
is visible. DashboardAlarmProviderStatus renders that combination as the amber
"Alarm Manager (no subtag standby)" badge rather than the failover label, which
would have named the wrong live provider.
- on the failover edge (ApplyProviderModeChangeAsync, toMode == Subtag) the
monitor re-resolves BEFORE publishing the status and reports any difference as
SubtagWatchListStale with both counts.
The re-resolution is deliberately NOT re-sent. The worker rejects a second
SubscribeAlarms while subscribed (AlarmCommandHandler.Subscribe), and the only
expressible replacement — UnsubscribeAlarms then SubscribeAlarms — rebuilds
FailoverAlarmConsumer, which restarts on the primary that just failed and
discards the warm standby state, so it would flap the feed rather than repair it.
The finding's other alternative (treat empty coverage as a lifecycle failure) was
rejected too: it would crash-loop the monitor every 5 s on a persistent GR outage
and take the working alarmmgr feed down with it. A monitor restart re-resolves and
re-sends, and the status now says so.
Docs: docs/AlarmClientDiscovery.md gains the grading rules and corrects two stale
claims (the resolver method name, and "re-runs discovery on its reconcile cadence
and pushes an updated watch-list", which never happened); gateway.md gains the
standby-coverage visibility paragraph; docs/GatewayConfiguration.md records the
consequence on the UseGalaxyRepository and Mode rows.
Tests: SubtagCoverage_WhenDiscoveryFailsAtSubscribe_ProviderStatusIsDegradedWith-
Reason and SubtagCoverage_WhenDiscoveryRecoversByFailover_ReResolvesAndReportsDrift
drive the fake-worker monitor; two resolver cases pin the new provenance fields.
The pre-existing dashboard case for degraded+ALARMMGR now asserts the new label.
The worker reports startup failures as structured WorkerFault frames --
MxAccessCreationException carries the COM HRESULT/ProgID context and a
WorkerFaultCategory -- so the gateway can tell "MXAccess is not installed / not
registered / access denied" apart from a pipe-level protocol problem.
ReadHandshakeEnvelopeAsync did not look inside: any body other than the expected
one became a ProtocolViolation naming only the body type, and that text is what
SessionManager puts in the operator log and the client's OpenFailed detail. The
information was lost exactly in the window where it matters most -- first
session open on a freshly deployed host, where the answer is almost always an
MXAccess installation or permission problem.
Special-case BodyCase == WorkerFault and throw WorkerClientException(
WorkerFaulted, CreateWorkerFaultMessage(...)) -- the same formatter the
steady-state fault path already uses, so both windows read alike. Every other
unexpected body still gets ProtocolViolation.
Test: StartAsync_WhenWorkerFaultsDuringHandshake_SurfacesFaultCategoryAndDiagnostic
has the fake worker answer the hello and then write a WorkerFault
{MxaccessCreationFailed} in place of WorkerReady; the existing
FakeWorkerHarness.EmitFaultAsync covered it, so the harness needed no change.
IPC-08 closed with WorkerCancel sent from the gateway's own timeout arm only.
Its rationale -- the gateway has stopped waiting but the worker has not stopped
working, so a queued-but-not-started command should be dropped instead of
occupying the single STA behind a caller that is already gone -- applies exactly
as well to caller cancellation, which is the common abandonment path: gRPC
clients routinely set per-call deadlines shorter than the gateway's
CommandTimeout, and a client disconnect cancels the RPC's token. Both landed in
arms that removed the pending entry and returned silently, leaving the
correlation to execute in its turn. Under a retry storm against a slow provider
the STA works through dead commands while live callers queue behind them --
precisely the backlog the cancel exists to shorten.
- TrySendCancelForTimedOutCommand is now TrySendCancelForAbandonedCommand and
takes the reason string, since it serves both arms.
- Both caller-cancellation arms route through AbandonCommandOnCallerCancellation,
which sends the cancel under the same `removed` ownership gate as the timeout
arm (so a reply that won the race is never chased) and skips it once _stopCts
has fired, where the outbound channel is being completed and every pending
command is failed anyway.
- New WorkerClientErrorCode.CallerCancelled replaces the GatewayShutdown label
those arms used, so metrics and logs stop recording a shutdown that did not
happen. It maps to StatusCode.Cancelled, the same status GatewayShutdown maps
to, so nothing changes for clients.
Docs: docs/Grpc.md mapping line, gateway.md cancellation rules,
docs/GatewayProcessDesign.md pending-command section.
Tests: InvokeAsync_WhenCallerCancels_SendsWorkerCancelForThatCorrelation (twin
of the timeout test, driven by the caller token; verified failing without the
send) and InvokeAsync_WhenClientStopsUnderInFlightCommand_DoesNotSendWorkerCancel.
Joseph Doherty
dohertj2