Files touched — docs/drivers/Modbus-Test-Fixture.md dropped the key-files pointer at deleted Pymodbus/ + flipped "primary launcher is Docker, native fallback retained" framing to "Docker is the only supported launch path" (matching the code). docs/v2/dev-environment.md dropped the "skips both Docker + native-binary paths" parenthetical from AB_SERVER_ENDPOINT + flipped the "Native fallbacks" subsection to a one-liner that says Docker is the only supported path. docs/v2/modbus-test-plan.md rewrote §Harness from "pip install pymodbus + serve.ps1" setup pattern to "docker compose --profile <…> up" + updated the §PR 43 status bullet to point at Docker/profiles/. docs/v2/test-data-sources.md §"CI fixture (task #180)" rewrote the AB CIP section from "LocateBinary() picks binary off PATH" + GitHub Actions zip-download step to "Docker is the only supported reproducible build path" + docker compose GitHub Actions step; dropped the pinned-version SHA256 table + lock-file reference because the Dockerfile's LIBPLCTAG_TAG build-arg is the new pin.
Code docstrings + error messages — these are developer-facing operational text too. ModbusSimulatorFixture SkipReason strings (both branches) now point at `docker compose -f Docker/docker-compose.yml --profile standard up -d` instead of the deleted `Pymodbus\serve.ps1`; doc-comment at the top references Docker/docker-compose.yml. Snap7ServerFixture SkipReason strings + doc-comment point at Docker/docker-compose.yml instead of PythonSnap7/serve.ps1. S7_1500Profile.cs docstring updated. Modbus Dockerfile comment pointing at deleted tests/.../Pymodbus/README.md redirected to docs/drivers/Modbus-Test-Fixture.md. DL205Profile.cs + DL205StringQuirkTests.cs + S7_1500Profile.cs (in Modbus project) docstrings flipped from Pymodbus/*.json references to Docker/profiles/*.json.
Left untouched deliberately: docs/v2/implementation/exit-gate-phase-2-closed.md — that's a historical as-of-2026-04-18 snapshot documenting what was skipped at Phase 2 closure; rewriting would lose the date-stamped context. Its "oitc/modbus-server Docker container not started" + "ab_server binary not on PATH" lines describe the fixture landscape that existed at close time, not current operational guidance.
Final sweep confirms zero remaining `Pymodbus/` / `PythonSnap7/` / `LocateBinary` / `AbServerSeedTag` / `BuildCliArgs` / `AbServerPlcArg` mentions anywhere in tracked files outside that historical exit-gate doc. Whole-solution build still 0 errors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Modbus — deletes tests/.../Modbus.IntegrationTests/Pymodbus/ (serve.ps1, standard.json, dl205.json, mitsubishi.json, s7_1500.json, README.md). Profile JSONs live only under Docker/profiles/ now. Docker/README.md loses its "Native-Python fallback" section; docs/drivers/Modbus-Test-Fixture.md "What the fixture is" bullet flipped from "primary launcher is Docker, native fallback under Pymodbus/" to "Docker is the only supported launch path".
S7 — deletes tests/.../S7.IntegrationTests/PythonSnap7/ (server.py, s7_1500.json, serve.ps1, README.md). Docker/README.md loses "Native-Python fallback"; docs/drivers/S7-Test-Fixture.md updated to match.
AB CIP — the biggest simplification because the native-binary spawn had the most code. AbServerFixture.cs rewrites: drops Process management (no more Process _proc + Kill/WaitForExit), drops LocateBinary() PATH lookup, drops the IAsyncLifetime initialize-spawns-server behavior. Fixture is now a thin TCP probe against localhost:44818 (or AB_SERVER_ENDPOINT override) — same shape as Snap7ServerFixture / ModbusSimulatorFixture / OpcPlcFixture. IsServerAvailable() simplifies to a single 500 ms probe. AbServerProfile.cs drops AbServerPlcArg + SeedTags + BuildCliArgs + ToCliSpec + the entire AbServerSeedTag record — the compose file is the canonical source of truth for which tags + which --plc mode each family gets; the profile record now carries just Family + ComposeProfile (matches the docker-compose service key) + Notes. KnownProfiles.ForFamily + .All stay for tests that iterate families. AbServerProfileTests.cs rewrites to match: drops BuildCliArgs_* + ToCliSpec_* + SeedTags_* tests; keeps the family-coverage contract tests + verifies the ComposeProfile strings match compose-file service names (a typo in either surfaces as a unit-test failure, not a silent "wrong family booted" at runtime). Docker/README.md loses "Native-binary fallback" section; docs/drivers/AbServer-Test-Fixture.md "What the fixture is" flipped to Docker-only with clearer skip rules.
dev-environment.md §Docker fixtures — the "Native fallbacks" subsection goes away; replaced with a one-line note that Docker is the only supported path for these four fixtures + a fresh clone needs Docker Desktop and nothing else.
Verified: whole-solution build 0 errors, AB CIP profile unit tests 6/6, AB CIP Docker smoke 4/4 (all family theory rows), S7 Docker smoke 3/3. Container lifecycle clean. The deleted native code surface was already redundant — every fixture the native paths served is now covered by Docker; keeping them invited drift between the two paths (the original AB CIP native profile had three undetected bugs per the #162 commit message: case-sensitive --plc, bracket tag notation, --path=1,0 requirement — noise the Docker path now avoids by never running the buggy code).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three substantive issues caught + fixed during the validation pass:
1. pymodbus rejects unknown keys at device-list / setup level. My PR 43 commit had `_layout_note`, `_uint16_layout`, `_bits_layout`, `_write_note` device-level JSON-comment fields that crashed pymodbus startup with `INVALID key in setup`. Removed all device-level _* fields. Inline `_quirk` keys WITHIN individual register entries are tolerated by pymodbus 3.13.0 — kept those in dl205.json since they document the byte math per quirk and the README + git history aren't enough context for a hand-author reading raw integer values. Documented the constraint in the top-level _comment of each profile.
2. pymodbus rejects sweeping `write` ranges that include any cell not assigned a type. My initial standard.json had `write: [[0, 2047]]` but only seeded HR[0..31] + HR[100] + HR[200..209] + bits[1024..1109] — pymodbus blew up on cell 32 (gap between HR[31] and HR[100]). Fixed by listing per-block write ranges that exactly mirror the seeded ranges. Same fix in dl205.json (was `[[0, 16383]]`).
3. pymodbus simulator stores all 4 standard Modbus tables in ONE underlying cell array — each cell can only be typed once (BITS or UINT16, not both). My initial standard.json had `bits[0..31]` AND `uint16[0..31]` overlapping at the same addresses; pymodbus crashed with `ERROR "uint16" <Cell> used`. Fixed by relocating coils to address 1024+, well clear of the uint16 entries at 0..209. Documented the layout constraint in the standard.json top-level _comment.
Substantive driver bug fixed: ModbusTcpTransport.ConnectAsync was using `new TcpClient()` (default constructor — dual-stack, IPv6 first) then `ConnectAsync(host, port)` with the user's hostname. .NET's TcpClient default-resolves "localhost" to ::1 first, fails to connect to pymodbus (which binds 0.0.0.0 IPv4-only), and only then retries IPv4 — the failure surfaces as the entire ConnectAsync timeout (2s by default) before the IPv4 attempt even starts. PR 30's smoke test silently SKIPPED because the fixture's TCP probe hit the same dual-stack ordering and timed out. Both fixed: ModbusSimulatorFixture probe now resolves Dns.GetHostAddresses, prefers AddressFamily.InterNetwork, dials IPv4 explicitly. ModbusTcpTransport does the same — resolves first, prefers IPv4, falls back to whatever Dns returns (handles IPv6-only hosts in the future). This is a real production-readiness fix because most Modbus PLCs are IPv4-only — a generic dual-stack TcpClient would burn the entire connect timeout against any IPv4-only PLC, masquerading as a connection failure when the PLC is actually fine.
Smoke-test address shifted HR[100] -> HR[200]. Standard.json's HR[100] is the auto-incrementing register that drives subscribe-and-receive tests, so write-then-read against it would race the increment. HR[200] is the first cell of a writable scratch range present in BOTH simulator profiles. DL205Profile.cs xml-doc updated to explain the shift; tag name "DL205_Smoke_HReg100" -> "Smoke_HReg200" + smoke test references updated. dl205.json gains a matching scratch HR[200..209] range so the smoke test runs identically against either profile.
Validation matrix:
- standard.json boot: clean (TCP 5020 listening within ~3s of pymodbus.simulator launch).
- dl205.json boot: clean.
- pymodbus client direct FC06 to HR[200]=1234 + FC03 read: round-trip OK.
- raw-bytes PowerShell TcpClient FC06 + 12-byte response: matches FC06 spec (echo of address + value).
- DL205SmokeTest against standard.json: 1/1 pass (was failing as 'BadInternalError' due to the dual-stack timeout + tag-name typo — both fixed).
- DL205SmokeTest against dl205.json: 1/1 pass.
- Modbus.Tests Unit suite: 52/52 pass — dual-stack transport fix is non-breaking.
- Solution build clean.
Memory + future-PR setup: pymodbus install + activation pattern is now bullet-pointed at the top of Pymodbus/README.md so future PRs (the per-quirk DL205_<behavior> tests in PR 44+) don't have to repeat the trial-and-error of getting the simulator + integration tests cooperating. The three bugs above are documented inline in the JSON profiles + ModbusTcpTransport so they don't bite again.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
ModbusSimulatorFixture default port bumped from 502 to 5020 to match the pymodbus convention. Override via MODBUS_SIM_ENDPOINT for a real PLC on its native 502. Skip-message updated to point at the new Pymodbus\serve.ps1 wrapper instead of 'start ModbusPal'. csproj <None Update> rule swapped from ModbusPal/** to Pymodbus/** so the new JSON profiles + serve.ps1 + README copy to test-output as PreserveNewest.
standard.json — generic Modbus TCP server, slave id 1, port 5020, shared blocks=false (independent coils + HR address spaces, more textbook-PLC-like). HR[0..31] seeded with address-as-value via per-register uint16 entries, HR[100] auto-increments via the built-in increment action with parameters minval=0/maxval=65535 (drives subscribe-and-receive integration tests so they have a register that ticks without a write — pymodbus's increment ticks per-access not wall-clock, which is good enough for a 250ms-poll test), HR[200..209] scratch range left at 0 for write tests, coils 0..31 alternating, coils 100..109 scratch. write list covers 0..1023 so any test address is mutable.
dl205.json — AutomationDirect DirectLOGIC DL205/DL260 quirk simulator, slave id 1, port 5020, shared blocks=true (matches DL series memory model where coils/DI/HR overlay the same word address space). Each quirky register seeded with the pre-computed raw uint16 value documented in docs/v2/dl205.md, with an inline _quirk JSON-comment naming the behavior so future-me reading the file knows why HR[1040]=25928 means 'H' lo / 'e' hi (the user's headline string-byte-order finding). Encoded quirks: V0 marker at HR[0]=0xCAFE; V2000 at HR[1024]=0x2000; V40400 at HR[8448]=0x4040; 'Hello' string at HR[1040..1042] first-char-low-byte; Float32 1.5f at HR[1056..1057] in CDAB word order (low word first); BCD register at HR[1072]=0x1234; FC03-128-cap block at HR[1280..1407]; Y0/C0 coil markers at 2048/3072; scratch C-relays at 4000..4007.
serve.ps1 wrapper — pwsh script with a -Profile {standard|dl205} parameter switch. Validates pymodbus.simulator is on PATH (clearer message than the raw CommandNotFoundException), validates the profile JSON exists, builds the right --modbus_server/--modbus_device/--json_file/--http_port arg list, and execs pymodbus.simulator in the foreground. -HttpPort 0 disables the web UI. Foreground exec lets the operator Ctrl+C to stop without an extra control script.
README.md fully rewritten for pymodbus: install command (pip install 'pymodbus[simulator]==3.13.0' — pinned for reproducibility, [simulator] extra pulls aiohttp), per-profile reference tables, the same DL205 quirk → register table from PR 42 but adjusted for pymodbus paths, what's-NEW-vs-ModbusPal section (all four tables, raw uint16 seeding, declarative actions, custom Python action modules, headless, web UI, maintained), trade-offs section (float32-as-two-uint16s for explicit CDAB control, increment ticks per-access not wall-clock, shared-blocks mode for DL205 vs separate for Standard), file-format quick reference for hand-authoring more profiles. References pinned to the pymodbus readthedocs simulator/config + REST API pages.
docs/v2/modbus-test-plan.md harness section rewritten with the swap rationale; PR-history list updated to mark PR 42 SUPERSEDED by PR 43 and call out PR 44+ as the per-quirk implementation track. Test-conventions bullet about 'don't depend on ModbusPal state between tests' generalized to 'don't depend on simulator state' and a note added that pymodbus's REST API can reset state between facts if a test ever needs it.
DL205Profile.cs and DL205SmokeTests.cs xml-doc updated to reference pymodbus / dl205.json instead of ModbusPal / DL205.xmpp.
Functional validation deferred — Python isn't installed on this dev box (winget search returned no matches for Python.Python.3 exact). JSON parses structurally (PowerShell ConvertFrom-Json clean on both files), build clean, .json + serve.ps1 + README all copy to test-output as expected. User installs pymodbus when they want to actually run the simulator end-to-end; if pymodbus rejects the config the README's reference link to pymodbus's simulator/config schema doc is the right next stop.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Standard.xmpp — generic Modbus TCP server on port 502, slave id 1. HR[0..31] seeded with address-as-value (HR[5]=5 — easy mental map for diagnostics), HR[100] auto-incrementing via a 1Hz LinearGenerator binding (drives subscribe-and-receive integration tests so they have a register that actually changes without a write), HR[200..209] scratch range for write-roundtrip tests, coils 0..31 alternating on/off, coils 100..109 scratch. The Tick automation runs 0..65535 over 60s looping; bound to HR[100] via Binding_SINT16 — slow enough that a 250ms-poll integration test sees discrete jumps, fast enough that a 5s subscribe test sees several change notifications.
DL205.xmpp — AutomationDirect DirectLOGIC DL205/DL260 quirk simulator on port 502, slave id 1, modeling the behaviors documented in docs/v2/dl205.md as concrete register values so DL205 integration tests can assert each quirk WITHOUT a live PLC. Per-quirk encoding: V0 marker at HR[0]=0xCAFE proves register 0 is valid (rejects-register-0 rumour disproved); V2000 marker at HR[1024]=0x2000 proves V-memory octal-to-decimal mapping; V40400 marker at HR[8448]=0x4040 proves V40400→PDU 0x2100 (NOT register 0, contrary to the widespread shorthand); 'Hello' string at HR[1040..1042] packed first-char-low-byte (HR[1040]=0x6548 = 'H' lo + 'e' hi, HR[1041]=0x6C6C, HR[1042]=0x006F) — the headline string-byte-order quirk the user flagged; Float32 1.5f at HR[1056..1057] in CDAB word order (low word first: 0, then 0x3FC0); BCD register at HR[1072]=0x1234 representing decimal 1234 in BCD nibbles (NOT binary 0x04D2); 128-register block at HR[1280..1407] for FC03-128-cap testing; Y0 marker at coil 2048, C0 marker at coil 3072, scratch C-coils at 4000..4007 for write tests.
Critical limitation flagged inline + in README: ModbusPal 1.6b CANNOT represent the DL205 quirks semantically — it has no string binding, no BCD binding, no arbitrary-byte-layout binding (only SINT16/SINT32/FLOAT32 with word-order). So every DL205 quirk is encoded as a pre-computed raw 16-bit integer with the math worked out in inline comments above each register. Becomes unreadable past ~50 quirky registers; the README's 'alternatives' section recommends switching to pymodbus when that threshold approaches (pymodbus's ModbusSimulatorServer has first-class headless + scriptable callbacks for byte-level layouts).
Other ModbusPal 1.6b limitations called out in README: only holding_registers + coils sections in the official build (no input_registers / discrete_inputs — DL260 X-input markers can't be encoded faithfully here, FC02/FC04 tests wait for a fork or pymodbus); abandoned project (last release 1.6b, active forks at SCADA-LTS/ModbusPal, ControlThings-io/modbuspal, mrhenrike/ModbusPalEnhanced); no headless mode in the official JAR (-loadFile / -hide flags only in source-built forks); CVE-2018-10832 XXE on .xmpp import (don't import untrusted profiles — the in-repo ones are author-controlled).
README.md updated with: per-profile description tables, getting-started (download jar + java -jar + GUI File>Load>Run), MODBUS_SIM_ENDPOINT env-var override doc, two reference tables documenting which HR / coil address encodes which DL205 quirk + which test name asserts it (the same DL205_<behavior> naming convention from docs/v2/modbus-test-plan.md), 4-row alternatives comparison (pymodbus / diagslave / ModbusMechanic / ModRSsim2) for when ModbusPal can no longer carry the load, and a quick-reference XML format table at the bottom for future-me hand-authoring more profiles.
Pure documentation + test-asset PR — no code changes. The integration tests that consume these profiles (the actual DL205_<behavior> facts) land one at a time in PR 43+ as user validates each quirk via ModbusPal on the bench.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
ModbusSimulatorFixture is a collection fixture so the 2s TCP probe runs once per run, not per test; SkipReason gets a clear operator-facing message ('start ModbusPal or override MODBUS_SIM_ENDPOINT'). Tests call Assert.Skip(sim.SkipReason) rather than silently returning — matches the test-plan convention and reads cleanly in CI logs. DL205Profile.BuildOptions deliberately disables the background probe loop since integration tests drive reads explicitly and the probe would race with assertions. Tag naming uses the DL205_ prefix so filter 'DisplayName~DL205' surfaces device-specific failures at a glance.
Project references: xunit.v3 + Shouldly + Microsoft.NET.Test.Sdk + xunit.runner.visualstudio (matches the existing Driver.Modbus.Tests unit project), project ref to src/Driver.Modbus. Registered in ZB.MOM.WW.OtOpcUa.slnx under tests/. ModbusPal/README.md documents the dev loop (install ModbusPal jar, load profile, start simulator, dotnet test), explains MODBUS_SIM_ENDPOINT override for real-PLC benchwork, and flags DL205.xmpp as the first profile to add in a follow-up PR.
dotnet test run against the scaffold (no simulator running) skips cleanly: 0 failed, 0 passed, 1 skipped, with the SkipReason surfaced. dotnet build clean (0 warnings, 0 errors). Updated docs/v2/modbus-test-plan.md to mark the scaffold PR done and renumbered future PRs from 'PR 27+' to 'PR 31+' to stay in sync with the actual PR chain.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
