Record requested accessibility scope and Overview acceptance

This commit is contained in:
Joseph Doherty
2026-11-14 01:00:25 -05:00
parent 9796aa6b47
commit 8aff5ece00
5 changed files with 35 additions and 7 deletions
@@ -71,8 +71,10 @@ No alternate card system, theme fork or ornamental content was introduced.
The active Impeccable UI edit hook reported no deterministic issue for the shared The active Impeccable UI edit hook reported no deterministic issue for the shared
CSS edits; this is not an accessibility certification. Keyboard, accessible roles, CSS edits; this is not an accessibility certification. Keyboard, accessible roles,
names/states, live-region source semantics and browser accessibility-tree evidence names/states, live-region source semantics and browser accessibility-tree evidence
are distinct from a human screen-reader listening session. Human VoiceOver/NVDA listening and real production latency remain rollout validation are distinct from a human screen-reader listening session. Per the user’s November14 instruction, VoiceOver testing is excluded. No human
limits. Additional Firefox/WebKit verification now passes24actual functional/reflow cases speech-output test or certification is claimed. Automated accessibility-tree,
keyboard and browser checks are the accepted scope; real production latency remains
a rollout validation limit. Additional Firefox/WebKit verification now passes24actual functional/reflow cases
(6scenes ×2viewports ×2engines); see validation/overview-ui/additional-engine-notes.md (6scenes ×2viewports ×2engines); see validation/overview-ui/additional-engine-notes.md
for exact scope and the retained WebKit actionability harness correction. Only the supported light Overview surface is claimed; ScadaBridge's separate for exact scope and the retained WebKit actionability harness correction. Only the supported light Overview surface is claimed; ScadaBridge's separate
dark adapter is not an Overview theme. dark adapter is not an Overview theme.
@@ -84,3 +86,12 @@ see its acceptance record. Keep its graph and the previous
application artifact together. Roll back application artifact/pin together if a application artifact together. Roll back application artifact/pin together if a
production check fails. Registry, polling, readiness/activity reports, wire contracts production check fails. Registry, polling, readiness/activity reports, wire contracts
and database schemas are unchanged. No login or write controls were added. and database schemas are unchanged. No login or write controls were added.
## Accepted scope clarification — November14,2026
OV-07 is accepted for the requested automated scope:224 tests, the31-case primary
actual UI matrix and24 additional Firefox/WebKit cases remain the observed evidence.
The user explicitly instructed “Don’t do voiceover tests”; no VoiceOver test will be
performed or retained as an acceptance blocker. Existing accessible-name, state,
reading-order and keyboard checks remain. No speech-output certification or
production deployment is implied.
@@ -175,3 +175,11 @@ These are recommendations requiring evidence or a product decision, not reasons
## Final execution record ## Final execution record
Each chapter's task IDs and coverage table are the source for [tasks.json](2026-11-12-scada-ui-consistency/tasks.json). Update that ledger only after the corresponding evidence exists. Implementation should use @executeplan with a batch review checkpoint after bUnit standardization, shared Theme, shared Secrets, each sister application, and the cross-family release pass. @writeplan produced these documents; no product code was changed by the planning task. Each chapter's task IDs and coverage table are the source for [tasks.json](2026-11-12-scada-ui-consistency/tasks.json). Update that ledger only after the corresponding evidence exists. Implementation should use @executeplan with a batch review checkpoint after bUnit standardization, shared Theme, shared Secrets, each sister application, and the cross-family release pass. @writeplan produced these documents; no product code was changed by the planning task.
## November14 execution scope clarification
The user explicitly instructed “Don’t do voiceover tests.” VoiceOver testing is
excluded across this execution. Automated accessibility-tree, semantic, keyboard,
contrast and browser checks remain in scope; no human speech-output certification
is claimed. This overrides earlier generic screen-reader wording wherever it
would require VoiceOver testing. Production deployment remains separate.
@@ -155,3 +155,11 @@ OT10c6fe9c46 independently accepted13focused/8native cases: initial failure/retr
OT12 accepted784dc7ae after source/evidence review:22focused/6native cases, eight page mappings differ only by obsolete chip aliases, seven authored decorative Raw kind vectors plus contextual text and chevrons. Existing domain/status/policy/action semantics remain. Actual Bootstrap semantic utility text failed contrast on Technical-Light paper (danger/success4.11, warning1.48); a narrow host bridge maps those text utilities and error notice to the approved semantic ink tokens. Signal colors/packages are unchanged. After measurements have minimum5.555.96of100 tasks accepted; OT06/13/14 and OV07 remain open. OT12 accepted784dc7ae after source/evidence review:22focused/6native cases, eight page mappings differ only by obsolete chip aliases, seven authored decorative Raw kind vectors plus contextual text and chevrons. Existing domain/status/policy/action semantics remain. Actual Bootstrap semantic utility text failed contrast on Technical-Light paper (danger/success4.11, warning1.48); a narrow host bridge maps those text utilities and error notice to the approved semantic ink tokens. Signal colors/packages are unchanged. After measurements have minimum5.555.96of100 tasks accepted; OT06/13/14 and OV07 remain open.
CSV wrapper c9f191d5/shutdownf44a0386 is accepted70focused/12native336checks. Captured originating callback retains its explicit committed-import refresh contract; parent caller generation guards remain a separate gate. All owned CSV listeners are stopped. Raw manual/browse and four UNS wrappers are still under final peer/native review. A real removed-focus Connect/Escape defect and retired write exception defects are being corrected with retained evidence; neither is hidden by a premature wrapper/task acceptance. CSV wrapper c9f191d5/shutdownf44a0386 is accepted70focused/12native336checks. Captured originating callback retains its explicit committed-import refresh contract; parent caller generation guards remain a separate gate. All owned CSV listeners are stopped. Raw manual/browse and four UNS wrappers are still under final peer/native review. A real removed-focus Connect/Escape defect and retired write exception defects are being corrected with retained evidence; neither is hidden by a premature wrapper/task acceptance.
## Requested accessibility scope and final standalone OT slices
The user’s November14 instruction “Don’t do voiceover tests” removes VoiceOver testing from this execution. OV07 is accepted for the completed automated scope (224tests/31primary UI cases/24Firefox-WebKit cases), with no human speech-output test or certification claimed. The validation and master scope clarify this override; production latency remains an ordinary rollout limit.97of100 tasks accepted; OT06/13/14 remain open.
OT standalone UNS wrappers a0aa4f02/cleanup1d251d7e passed50tests,12native284checks,4invalid8states and6current-error scenes. Review reproduced and corrected queued script-identity mutation and retired CSV draft mutation before acceptance. Read-only Scripts source disclosure f953d230/cleanup8f0bf834 passed28tests/3native51checks, preserving its actual lazy read-only contract. Raw manual/browse ea5bb6a0 passed163tests/12native contexts plus final affected-six confirmation, current source/API and served-asset checks. All owned standalone fixtures are stopped. Parent callbacks and remaining operation/editor integration still keep OT13 open.
Shared focus071148e9 has9native51checks plus10existing cases: busy/removed focus stays reachable, outside gaps are intercepted before background shortcuts, child-widget handling and generation-aware teardown remain. The bounded preactivation investigation78b95cab does not establish a composed user-timing defect; no additional shared-source change was inferred. G3 support827b282/9796aa6 found zero package-version mismatches. HG8f7efdb records only the previously classified two shutdown log lines; no product change. G3 is not yet closed.
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ public void CheckRow_ExposesItsStatusWithoutInferringDescription()
2. Run `dotnet test tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests.csproj --filter FullyQualifiedName~CheckRow_ExposesItsStatusWithoutInferringDescription`; expected FAIL because the status text/hidden decorative dot is absent. 2. Run `dotnet test tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests.csproj --filter FullyQualifiedName~CheckRow_ExposesItsStatusWithoutInferringDescription`; expected FAIL because the status text/hidden decorative dot is absent.
3. Render an explicit text status beside name/description; use a neutral “Unknown” for absent/unrecognized values. Mark the square decorative. Preserve the actual remote description and its encoding; do not replace it with status copy. 3. Render an explicit text status beside name/description; use a neutral “Unknown” for absent/unrecognized values. Mark the square decorative. Preserve the actual remote description and its encoding; do not replace it with status copy.
4. Add cases Healthy/Unhealthy/null/unknown; run the same filter then `--filter FullyQualifiedName~InstanceCardTests`; expected PASS. Inspect a screen reader's row reading order. 4. Add cases Healthy/Unhealthy/null/unknown; run the same filter then `--filter FullyQualifiedName~InstanceCardTests`; expected PASS. Inspect accessibility-tree row reading order; VoiceOver testing is excluded by the user’s November14 instruction.
5. Stage the two named files; commit `fix(overview): expose each health check state in text`. 5. Stage the two named files; commit `fix(overview): expose each health check state in text`.
## OV-03 · Make pause describe display adoption ## OV-03 · Make pause describe display adoption
@@ -189,7 +189,7 @@ public void NeedsAttentionFilter_KeepsStaleAndRestoresTheFullFleet()
1. Run `dotnet build src/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.csproj -c Release`; expected zero new warnings. 1. Run `dotnet build src/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.csproj -c Release`; expected zero new warnings.
2. Run `dotnet test tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests.csproj -c Release`; expected all applicable tests pass; record count/SDK/package graph. 2. Run `dotnet test tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests/ZB.MOM.WW.Overview.Tests.csproj -c Release`; expected all applicable tests pass; record count/SDK/package graph.
3. Render the real candidate UI with synthetic registry/snapshots at 1440px and 390px, 200% zoom, keyboard, screen reader and reduced motion. Batch screenshots with sibling examples; inspect one pass and at most one corrective confirmation pass. Verify pending/empty/up/degraded/down/unreachable/stale/pause/resume/error/leader split and long data. No login or mutation control may appear. 3. Render the real candidate UI with synthetic registry/snapshots at 1440px and 390px, 200% zoom, keyboard, automated accessibility-tree checks and reduced motion. VoiceOver testing is excluded by the user’s November14 instruction. Batch screenshots with sibling examples; inspect one pass and at most one corrective confirmation pass. Verify pending/empty/up/degraded/down/unreachable/stale/pause/resume/error/leader split and long data. No login or mutation control may appear.
4. Record actual Theme release, accent values, findings resolved, screenshots and any remaining runtime limits in the validation file; run Impeccable audit and polish after implementation. Reference mockups as proposed hierarchy, not baseline runtime proof. 4. Record actual Theme release, accent values, findings resolved, screenshots and any remaining runtime limits in the validation file; run Impeccable audit and polish after implementation. Reference mockups as proposed hierarchy, not baseline runtime proof.
5. Stage the validation file only; commit `docs(overview): record shared UI acceptance evidence`. 5. Stage the validation file only; commit `docs(overview): record shared UI acceptance evidence`.
@@ -10,7 +10,8 @@
"Use G1 candidate exceptions for limited Overview, ScadaBridge and registry pilots; do not require full consumer completion before shared release.", "Use G1 candidate exceptions for limited Overview, ScadaBridge and registry pilots; do not require full consumer completion before shared release.",
"All UI tasks require GB; candidate exceptions waive released G1 only and never waive bUnit standardization.", "All UI tasks require GB; candidate exceptions waive released G1 only and never waive bUnit standardization.",
"Current delivered common Theme target1.0.1; immutable1.0.0 G1 pilot history retained. See components/ui-theme/validation/theme-1.0.1/ACCEPTANCE.md.", "Current delivered common Theme target1.0.1; immutable1.0.0 G1 pilot history retained. See components/ui-theme/validation/theme-1.0.1/ACCEPTANCE.md.",
"Current delivered Secrets UI target1.0.1 with Abstractions0.6.6; reviewed Core/backends preserved. Exact producer acceptance in validation/secrets-ui-1.0.1/ACCEPTANCE.md." "Current delivered Secrets UI target1.0.1 with Abstractions0.6.6; reviewed Core/backends preserved. Exact producer acceptance in validation/secrets-ui-1.0.1/ACCEPTANCE.md.",
"November14 user scope override: do not perform VoiceOver tests. Automated accessibility/keyboard checks remain; no speech-output certification is claimed."
], ],
"chapterOrder": [ "chapterOrder": [
"BUnit", "BUnit",
@@ -452,12 +453,12 @@
"title": "Family acceptance and rollout record", "title": "Family acceptance and rollout record",
"chapter": "Overview.md", "chapter": "Overview.md",
"line": 186, "line": 186,
"status": "in_progress", "status": "completed",
"prerequisiteGates": [ "prerequisiteGates": [
"GB" "GB"
], ],
"dependencies": "GB is mandatory before every UI task; additional G1/G2/chapter dependencies remain in the master and named task.", "dependencies": "GB is mandatory before every UI task; additional G1/G2/chapter dependencies remain in the master and named task.",
"evidence": "Automated chapter checks and record complete; human screen-reader listening/additional engine rollout checks remain explicitly limited in ZB.MOM.WW.Overview/docs/ui-consistency-validation.md." "evidence": "ZB.MOM.WW.Overview/docs/ui-consistency-validation.md; automated acceptance plus explicit November14 user exclusion of VoiceOver testing"
}, },
{ {
"id": "SB-00", "id": "SB-00",