Files
scadaproj/docs/plans/2026-11-12-scada-ui-consistency/EXECUTION.md
T

22 KiB
Raw Blame History

Execution checkpoint — November 13, 2026

Active objective: execute all 100 plan tasks, with all seven bUnit projects verified before any Theme/UI updates. This checkpoint is partial progress, not completion.

Worktree: /Users/dohertj2/.codex/worktrees/scada-ui-consistency/scadaproj; branch codex/scada-ui-consistency; source base 9c3ab5f.

Project Fresh before After 2.7.2 / parser 1.5.2 State
Theme 70 pass 70 pass verified
Secrets UI 34 pass 34 pass verified, clean-output confirmation
Overview 197 pass 197 pass verified, clean-output confirmation
ScadaBridge not run not run managed worktree pending
OtOpcUa not run not run managed worktree pending
HistorianGateway not run not run managed worktree pending
BTDB not run not run managed worktree pending

All three verified projects retain exact test identities/outcomes, zero failures/skips, clean transitive vulnerability reports and no production test-package leakage. Changes are test-only dependencies and fixture API migration. No Theme component/CSS/public API or app UI source was changed.

Parent pending worktree batch: functions cell g4:77. Agent pending cells: ScadaBridge g6:41, OtOpcUa g6:43, HistorianGateway g7:39. Calls are yielded/live, not reported as terminal errors. No corresponding sister worktrees or Git worktree-creation process were observed in the last read-only check. Do not duplicate/restart based solely on elapsed time. Poll these handles or inspect returned operation IDs if they arrive. The parent wrapper may report an already-existing branch/copy destination after worktree calls complete; those root setup operations were safely completed while the calls were pending.

GB remains OPEN. Do not start TH-01 or other shared/app UI tasks. Continue the four isolated migrations after real paths arrive; then close BU-01/BU-10 using fresh runtime evidence. Evidence: components/ui-theme/validation/bunit-2.7.2/.

Verified migration commits: Theme 9bda64e, Secrets UI f961042, Overview 8232f3a. The read-only managed-artifact inventory confirms only the scadaproj worktree is attached. No sister worktree path has been returned.

Blocked audit

The same managed-worktree prerequisite remained unresolved across three consecutive goal turns. The parent handle g4:77 is still live/yielded, not terminal; current Git registries again show no new sister worktrees. The existing ScadaBridge design worktree is unrelated and is not reused. No duplicate creation or original-checkout mutation is attempted.

Goal marked blocked pending an external worktree response or explicit user workflow override. All 100 tasks remain the objective; only BU-02/03/05/06 are complete. GB remains open at 3/7 and no Theme/UI work may start. Do not interpret this blocked status as goal completion or cancellation of pending creation calls.

User-authorized recovery

User replied “Authorized” to the explicit option to use existing sister checkouts. This overrides executeplan’s new-worktree requirement for those repositories. Parent request cell g4:77 was explicitly terminated because the workflow changed; it is not treated as a timeout failure or restarted. Child creation calls are being canceled by their owners. No new creation requests are made.

Proceed in clean existing sister checkouts on new codex/scada-ui-consistency branches, preserving concurrent user changes. Full before/after tests, graph/audit verification and GB remain mandatory. The full objective is resumed; shared Theme/UI work still waits for seven-project acceptance.

GB accepted — November 13, 2026

Independent audit closed all seven migrations: 5,879 passed, zero failures, 75 unchanged external integration skips. All runtime package hashes and identities verified. See components/ui-theme/validation/bunit-2.7.2/ACCEPTANCE.md. BU-01–BU-10 completed. Shared Theme/UI work starts only after this acceptance. The user-authorized existing-checkout workflow remains in effect.

Shared Theme source batch — November 13, 2026

TH-01 selects 1.0.0; published version remains 0.5.3 until G1. Semantic text suite reproduced 15 failing pairs before implementation and now passes16. Full integrated suite including field/busy/shell contracts and four light accent families passes105 tests, zero failures/skips. Field associations and busytext are additive; source domain behavior is unchanged. Real Overview and disposable actual CentralUI hosts reproduced reduced-motion rise animation before focus/motion changes. Source and docs now implement focus/reduced-motion recipes. Offline exporter initially passed13tests; independent review caught filesystemaliases permitting input overwrite, fixed with samefile guard and two regressions (15 green). Another review caught README emptyerror handling; corrected to the component's absence semantics.

Actual package/static export, computed styles, slow action/focus flows, supported dark aliases and canary browser matrix remain open. No consumer adoption, feed publication or deployment is claimed. Candidate-source version is1.0.0; exact immutable artifact/source revision will be recorded only after clean source commit and canaries.

G1 accepted — November 13, 2026

Published exact Theme 1.0.0 package and canonical static export from clean source commit 3d61456d61. Independent downloads and isolated official-feed Overview restore match reviewed hashes. Theme105, Overview197, ScadaBridge1551, registry11, exporter15 and importer6 checks pass; detailed scope/raw results and independent review are under components/ui-theme/validation/theme-1.0.0/. No app deployment occurred. G1 is passed; G2/G3 and broader consumer tasks remain open. TH-01–TH-08 completed; TH-09 retains future G2 comparison/extraction decision. Limited Overview adoption commit70c5aa2, ScadaBridge pilot cdd3adf6, registry import018f504. Root owns Overview, gateway_reviews owns Secrets, otopcua_review owns ScadaBridge, scadabridge_review owns ignitionoee. Consumer implementation now proceeds against this single immutable contract. Existing explicit-checkout authorization continues. No production secret/historian/native issue writes are authorized for QA.

Theme1.0.1 and Overview checkpoint — November13,2026

Compatible shared patch1.0.1 published from d8d633d, exact package/export independently downloaded and restored from official feed. All consumers now converge on1.0.1; 1.0.0 evidence remains immutable.105Theme/15exporter/224Overview pass. Actual Overview31-case matrix has no document overflow/page errors; filter/clear focus, pause aging/hold/resume, long escaped diagnostic keyboard access and reduced motion pass. OV01–06 completed; OV07 remains in progress for explicitly recorded human screen-reader/additional-engine runtime limits. Secrets01–04 accepted after69tests and two-host interaction verification;05–06 executing with81tests pending rendered acceptance. No G2/G3 completion or application deployment claimed.

MxAccessGateway clean existing checkout moved from main to authorized codex branch; pre-change dashboard341/341 passes. No COM/worker/proto/options/auth changes.

Native pilot and consumer checkpoint — November 13, 2026

MX native pilot committed260d58af plus raw evidence5a1daab9 in the authorized sister checkout. Framework HtmlRenderer remains;341 baseline identities retained and343 dashboard tests pass. Actual native/browser and focused deferred-import, disposal, focus fallback and validation-visibility checks pass. Native browser chrome focus is distinguished with document.hasFocus under W3C H102; no custom Tab trap. MX02 complete; MX01 starting. OEE02 may now perform its second native pilot. No generic dialog extraction is claimed.

Secrets05–06 committed46556db,81 tests and93 final two-host browser checks after exact official Theme1.0.1 restoration. The cached unpublished candidate was caught by served-byte checks; only its known root-created cache entry was removed/refilled. SEC07 minimal package/release compatibility work is in progress, publication held for independent artifact review. SB01–02 committed87c882ec; exact Theme1.0.1 pin 20885b61 has1557 full tests. SB03 composite/help acceptance still in progress. OEE01/05/06/07 observed source/test/browser proofs accepted; remaining native and cross-page contracts remain in progress. G2/G3 and whole100-task objective stay open.

Producer patch and consumer checkpoint — November13,2026

Secrets UI1.0.0/Abstractions0.6.6 delivery passed legacy66 checks and actual two-host44 checks. Subsequent dark composition exposed two obsolete metadata color fallbacks (2.658:1). UI1.0.1 centrally fixes them; independent review,81 source tests, exact official publication and empty package/HTTP cache inference/two-host builds passed. Actual dark6.761/light5.564 contrasts verified. Consumers now target UI1.0.1/Abs0.6.6/Theme1.0.1 with Core/backends preserved. No deployment.

ScadaBridge03–12 accepted through9dbfe7bc,1591full tests and corrected actual light/dark/zoom/coarse proofs. MX01/03/07 acceptedc9a6c31c; MX04 narrow fault message correction is in progress. OEE02 native pilot plus frozen busy submissions accepted through ecf1380d (1705tests); OEE05 full long-rail acceptance51a546d8 supersedes its earlier representative evidence; OEE08 responsive/touch acceptedcac2e4e5. Native OEE runtime/theme acceptance, remaining projects and G2/G3 stay open.

Interaction convergence and ScadaBridge final checkpoint

G2 accepted with explicit managed/native comparison and retain-local extraction decision in validation/interaction-pilots/G2.md. Registry native Tab handling is recorded distinctly from MX/OEE router behavior; no generic component/package was introduced. TH09 is complete; G3 remains open.

ScadaBridge final d370dbd3 passes1597 tests, exact delivered shared package/runtime hashes and retained Core/backend pins. Deterministic slowA/fastB filter callback test caught older completion overwriting Last submitted; captured submitted state now updates before awaiting caller. SB00/13–15 complete. Full source route inventory is distinguished from representative actual-component runtime coverage. MX04b06921ce accepted nine actual overview cases; MX05/06/08 final package graph/build/browser acceptance and peer review are underway.

HistorianGateway and MXAccess final checkpoint

HistorianGateway92c9ae02 completes HG01–07:1467main+191client+206ownedclient passed,76unchanged external skips,0fail;35functional+36visual+13native-invalid cases. Native numeric/date drafts retain raw text and reject invalid/partial input before captured intent/dispatch. Existing Core/backends retained, exact shared UI1.0.1/Abs0.6.6/Theme1.0.1 delivered bytes verified.

MXAccess26a90883 completes MX01–08:1460passed/6existingplatform skips, actual MainLayout17cases+12active-title destinations, official3DLL/7asset parity, min semantic text contrast5.555. Independent review corrected focus-await tree identity/lifetime (2framework regressions) and native fault-detail DOM state transfer (actual compact/table red→green under prepend/reorder). No backend/protocol/policy changes. Owned MX canary stopped; no deployment. Root now assists disjoint OT13 protocol fields after OT01 pattern freeze; agent continues other OT tasks, another owns BTDB, OEE native final acceptance is under review. G3 remains open.

OEE convergence and identity followup

OEE chapter is complete through c155798e, including exact official Secrets UI1.0.1/Abs0.6.6 adoption with Core0.6.2 preserved,1705UI/211Host/105security passes and actual packaged Secrets1440/390/real200% checks. Native diagnostic target followup28ff7c91 is separately bounded to six actual cases,25targeted tests and31schemas; it does not claim a fresh full5999offline rerun. Native final proof/limits in OEE-chapter-exit.md remain authoritative. Only a newly created Designer Launcher card remains for manual cleanup on the locked Mac; owned runtime resources are stopped.

ScadaBridge6489c9fc closes an independently reproduced identity gap: old custom contexts and late activation rejections cannot complete a replacement presentation. Three actual regression failures retained before the fix;3focused/full1600passed after. No public API/domain change.

OT01–03 accepted169149f1 with bounded pilot proof; Monaco naming8cc053ce follows. OT04–06 and OT13 continue. All35default protocol field surfaces now render with names/unique IDs/resolved descriptions;12driver numeric parser checks preserve emitted config. Conditional-field and full root acceptance still pending. G3 remains open.

OT navigation and Overview engine checkpoint

OT04/05 acceptedcb3400c1 with25e78ebe list gates and1fe4dbf5 Overview gates: exact destination policy navigation, existing readable routes retained, retired namespace compatibility links preserved, compact truthful Home and shared scroll rail.18focused and12role/width scenes288checks pass, followed by bounded finalcopy/heading checks; residual list/Overview policy aggregate26passes. No endpoint policy or backend mutation. OT06 grammar source snapshots75ff3810/78a39a10/1fe4dbf5 independently preserve23business bodies; admin/cluster runtime acceptance still pendingOT14.

Overviewfb40fec adds24Firefox/WebKit functional/reflow cases after explicit browser installation. The WebKit Playwright closed-details visibility fallback was identified in installed driver source; actual measured native pointer input and resulting state/keyboard checks pass. No product patch was based on that harness discrepancy. OV07 retains only human screen-reader listening/production runtime limits, not the now-completed additional-engine checks.

Consumer lifecycle and touch checkpoint

BT00a7a694e/BT0175439ee accepted exact Theme1.0.1 graph, managed overlay generation/TCS/row guards,17nativeoverlaycases and6typed/19rowchecks. Separate86ba7ef patches only CLR test project's Pkcs9.0.21 after fullbuild exposed its oldertransitivegraph;53CLRtests passed, no production dependencydelta. Remaining BT tasks are in progress; later snapshot/Reload/device fullgate is not accepted by these earlier checkpoints.

OT08accepted78bad3a6: native completeescapeddiagnostics in5routes/DriverStatusPanel,31combinedfocused/27actualkeyboardcases. OT07acceptedc5a288b0: bounded localRawviewport,matching30/44rows+ItemSize,55–62mountedof800,500→800paging,25levelkeyboardpan,stablefocusedselectedDOMacrossdensitychanges,real200% andcoarse44targets. Final15owned-loopbackunitchecks and3enginenativeMenuparent/childEntereachdispatchonce+focusreturnpass. Earlier16nativecases/twozoomcaptureconfirmations retained. No Themefork/newrelease/domainoperation. ParentownsRawcaller/semanticCSS afterhandoff; rootownsnext7sharedprobeentryguards andthenFleet/Hosts read-state retention.

SQL evidence qualification: AdminUiSqlServerFixture can probeitsdefaultserverduringdiscoverybefore filters. Earlier filtered OT runs did notexecuteSQLcollections/write tests, but possible default readinessSELECT1 cannot be excluded. All remaining OT test commands nowuse the owned-loopback SQL environment runner; privatecredentials/state remainoutsideGit. A newlyprovisioned privateinstance passed9SQLpreflighttests with0skips; this is fixture readiness, not OT14 final acceptance. Native component canaries retain their separate synthetic/read-only service boundaries. G3 remainsopen.

BTDB chapter exit and remaining OT ownership

BT02–04/06–11 accepted through55631fa03f792df12aa2068fda8e644f70ef7f6d (BT00/01/05 already accepted). Final1019passed/28unchanged external-SQL skips/0fail/0warnings; baseline outcome comparison retains all prior tests apart from two explicitly replaced native Escape callback names. Actual61renders/3roles,56additional cases/9contrast pairs,85functional cases and45worker-tab cases are bounded in BTDB docs/ui-consistency/verification.md. Independent review caught and corrected captured-review payload changes, duplicate Reload confirmation, invalid nonblank severity, clean-clone membership, scoped theme dialog host and phone audit overflow. Exact delivered Theme1.0.1 DLL+6HTTP assets verified; all three owned BT canaries stopped. History5000 performance is a synthetic client measurement, not SQL capacity certification.

92of100 tasks are accepted. OT06/09/10/11/12/13/14 and OV07 remain open. Gateway agent owns seven shared probe lifecycle guards; root owns Fleet/Hosts stale refresh feedback, primary owns other remaining OT work and final SQL gates, modal agent owns five complex wrappers. No deployment or whole-goal completion is implied.

OT deployment, modal and refresh checkpoint

OT09 completedf7bc69e9 after independent source/hash/TRX/browser review:37focused including actual private-SQL50row/noArtifactBlob projection;24native feedback scenes. Accepted request, persisted status and applied/sealed outcomes remain distinct. Last successful history survives failed refresh and missing actor replies remain unconfirmed rather than rejected. No actor/backend/policy semantics changed.

OT13 complexfive79acb80d/cleanup88be7734 passed independent review:233focused,15native627checks andtwo390/real200 invalid-focus/recovery contexts. Current getter remains live; retired child getters retain frozenA configuration and never readB/default protocol JSON. Seven sharedprobe guards43a3512b pass184focused; dynamicMonacoReadOnlyb4f7672d passes29focused, with additional late-create disposal review still open. Wrapper callers and remaining UNS/Raw/inline surfaces keep OT13 open.

Root OT11 Fleet/Hosts7c888d1d retains last-good rows/enrichment, separate acquired/error clocks, initial unavailable/retry and manual-only busy/success feedback.40tests0skips include actual private-SQL first-query success/second-query rejection without partial config installation;12native1440/390/real200 cases confirm retryfocus/rows/time/firstfailure stability. Root host18140 stopped. Live-tail pages remain primary-owned, so OT11 remains open.93of100 tasks accepted; remaining OT06/10/11/12/13/14 and OV07 stay open, G3 not closed.

Tree recovery and live-tail acceptance

OT10c6fe9c46 independently accepted13focused/8native cases: initial failure/retry remains on-page, loaded-only UNS filtering/clear preserves loaded structure and focus, deep content stays in a named local scroll region at195CSSpx/real200. No hidden server-search/lazy-fetch claim. OT11 combines root7c888d1d refresh retention with tails6bb5a313:11tail tests/8first native cases, immutable displayed snapshots freeze during bounded collection, Resume adopts latest window, Clear preserves pause and affects only the visible window. Connection/pause alone is live; payload/counts remain outside live regions. Existing500script/200alert capacities are retained. Root verified buffer snapshot identity and source logic before acceptance.95of100 tasks accepted; OT06/12/13/14 and OV07 remain open. Shared Monaco50942b4a prevents retired/disconnected pending creation from installing an editor/diagnostic callback;30managed+3production-JS harness scenes17checks pass. Remaining Raw/UNS wrappers and composed callers remain under active review, not accepted by this checkpoint.

Canonical OT presentation checkpoint

OT12 accepted784dc7ae after source/evidence review:22focused/6native cases, eight page mappings differ only by obsolete chip aliases, seven authored decorative Raw kind vectors plus contextual text and chevrons. Existing domain/status/policy/action semantics remain. Actual Bootstrap semantic utility text failed contrast on Technical-Light paper (danger/success4.11, warning1.48); a narrow host bridge maps those text utilities and error notice to the approved semantic ink tokens. Signal colors/packages are unchanged. After measurements have minimum5.555.96of100 tasks accepted; OT06/13/14 and OV07 remain open.

CSV wrapper c9f191d5/shutdownf44a0386 is accepted70focused/12native336checks. Captured originating callback retains its explicit committed-import refresh contract; parent caller generation guards remain a separate gate. All owned CSV listeners are stopped. Raw manual/browse and four UNS wrappers are still under final peer/native review. A real removed-focus Connect/Escape defect and retired write exception defects are being corrected with retained evidence; neither is hidden by a premature wrapper/task acceptance.

Requested accessibility scope and final standalone OT slices

The user’s November14 instruction “Don’t do voiceover tests” removes VoiceOver testing from this execution. OV07 is accepted for the completed automated scope (224tests/31primary UI cases/24Firefox-WebKit cases), with no human speech-output test or certification claimed. The validation and master scope clarify this override; production latency remains an ordinary rollout limit.97of100 tasks accepted; OT06/13/14 remain open.

OT standalone UNS wrappers a0aa4f02/cleanup1d251d7e passed50tests,12native284checks,4invalid8states and6current-error scenes. Review reproduced and corrected queued script-identity mutation and retired CSV draft mutation before acceptance. Read-only Scripts source disclosure f953d230/cleanup8f0bf834 passed28tests/3native51checks, preserving its actual lazy read-only contract. Raw manual/browse ea5bb6a0 passed163tests/12native contexts plus final affected-six confirmation, current source/API and served-asset checks. All owned standalone fixtures are stopped. Parent callbacks and remaining operation/editor integration still keep OT13 open.

Shared focus071148e9 has9native51checks plus10existing cases: busy/removed focus stays reachable, outside gaps are intercepted before background shortcuts, child-widget handling and generation-aware teardown remain. The bounded preactivation investigation78b95cab does not establish a composed user-timing defect; no additional shared-source change was inferred. G3 support827b282/9796aa6 found zero package-version mismatches. HG8f7efdb records only the previously classified two shutdown log lines; no product change. G3 is not yet closed.