src/MxGateway.Worker/MxAccess/MxAccessAlarmEventSink.cs

@@ -4,33 +4,80 @@ using MxGateway.Contracts.Proto;
 namespace MxGateway.Worker.MxAccess;
 
 /// <summary>
-///     PR A.2 — sink that registers against the MXAccess Toolkit's alarm event
-///     source and forwards each alarm transition into the worker's event queue
-///     as an <see cref="OnAlarmTransitionEvent"/>. Sister to
-///     <see cref="MxAccessBaseEventSink"/>, but for the alarm event family
-///     instead of data-change.
+///     PR A.2 sink intended to register against an MXAccess alarm event source
+///     and forward each alarm transition into the worker's event queue as an
+///     <see cref="OnAlarmTransitionEvent"/>. The mapper bridge is fully
+///     implemented + unit-tested via
+///     <see cref="MxAccessEventMapper.CreateOnAlarmTransition"/>; the
+///     <see cref="Attach"/> path is intentionally a no-op pending the
+///     architectural decision documented below.
 /// </summary>
 /// <remarks>
 ///     <para>
-///         The MXAccess Toolkit's alarm subscription API differs across major
-///         AVEVA versions. The exact COM interface (today expected to be one of
-///         <c>IAlarmEventSink</c>, <c>IAlarmEventSubscription</c>, or a method
-///         on the existing <c>LMXProxyServerClass</c> like
-///         <c>OnAlarmEvent</c>) is pinned during dev-rig validation against the
-///         worker host's installed Toolkit version. Until that pin lands, the
-///         <see cref="Attach"/> path logs a clear "alarm subscription not yet
-///         wired" warning and registers no COM hook — the worker continues to
-///         function for data subscriptions, and the gateway's
-///         <see cref="MxEventFamily.OnAlarmTransition"/> path simply receives no
-///         events.
+///         <strong>2026-04-30 dev-rig finding:</strong> the MXAccess COM
+///         Toolkit installed at <c>C:\Program Files (x86)\ArchestrA\Framework\Bin\ArchestrA.MXAccess.dll</c>
+///         does <strong>not</strong> expose any alarm event family. Reflection
+///         enumeration of the assembly (which exports a single COM interop
+///         module containing <c>ILMXProxyServerEvents</c> and
+///         <c>ILMXProxyServerEvents2</c>) confirms the only available events
+///         are <c>OnDataChange</c>, <c>OnWriteComplete</c>,
+///         <c>OperationComplete</c>, and <c>OnBufferedDataChange</c>. There is
+///         no <c>OnAlarmTransition</c>, no <c>IAlarmEventSink</c>, and no
+///         <c>Alarms</c> collection on the COM server.
 ///     </para>
 ///     <para>
-///         <see cref="MxAccessEventMapper.CreateOnAlarmTransition"/> is fully
-///         implemented and unit-testable — it builds the proto event from
-///         decoded fields, so once the COM subscription resolves to a method
-///         that produces those fields, the only edit needed here is to wire
-///         the COM event-handler delegate to call
-///         <see cref="EnqueueTransition"/>.
+///         AVEVA's separate alarm-subscription managed assemblies
+///         (<c>aaAlarmManagedClient.dll</c> under
+///         <c>InTouch\ViewAppFramework\Content\MA\</c>,
+///         <c>ArchestrAAlarmsAndEvents.SDK.Common.dll</c> under
+///         <c>Wonderware\Historian\x64\</c>) are present on this box but are
+///         <strong>x64-only</strong>; they cannot load into the worker process,
+///         which is x86 because of the MXAccess COM bitness constraint that
+///         the <c>mxaccessgw</c> architecture exists to isolate. Loading them
+///         in a separate x64 helper process would add meaningful operational
+///         complexity (a third process tier alongside worker + gateway) and is
+///         not in the current architecture.
+///     </para>
+///     <para>
+///         <strong>Two paths forward — operator decision needed before the
+///         sink can be wired:</strong>
+///     </para>
+///     <list type="number">
+///         <item>
+///             <description>
+///                 <strong>Stay on the value-driven sub-attribute path</strong>
+///                 (current production behaviour). The lmxopcua server's
+///                 <c>AlarmConditionService</c> already synthesizes Part 9
+///                 transitions from the four MXAccess sub-attributes
+///                 (<c>InAlarm</c>, <c>Acked</c>, <c>Priority</c>,
+///                 <c>Description</c>) via the data-change subscription.
+///                 Operator-comment fidelity is the only regression vs. v1; if
+///                 acceptable, this row stays the production path and the
+///                 <see cref="MxEventFamily.OnAlarmTransition"/> family stays
+///                 reserved-but-dormant on the wire.
+///             </description>
+///         </item>
+///         <item>
+///             <description>
+///                 <strong>Add an x64 alarm-helper sub-process</strong> alongside
+///                 the worker that loads <c>aaAlarmManagedClient</c>,
+///                 subscribes to alarms, and forwards transitions to the worker
+///                 over a small named-pipe IPC. Then this sink's
+///                 <see cref="Attach"/> connects to that helper instead of to
+///                 the COM server, and routes each transition through
+///                 <see cref="EnqueueTransition"/>. Adds operational complexity
+///                 but recovers full v1 fidelity (operator user, comment,
+///                 original raise time, category).
+///             </description>
+///         </item>
+///     </list>
+///     <para>
+///         Until that decision is made, this sink's <see cref="Attach"/> is a
+///         no-op. The worker continues to function for data subscriptions, and
+///         the gateway's <see cref="MxEventFamily.OnAlarmTransition"/> family
+///         is reserved on the wire but never emitted. lmxopcua-side
+///         <c>AlarmConditionService</c> keeps the sub-attribute synthesis
+///         active and continues to surface alarms to OPC UA Part 9 clients.
 ///     </para>
 /// </remarks>
 public sealed class MxAccessAlarmEventSink : IMxAccessEventSink