{"title":"Phase 3 PR 54 -- Siemens S7 Modbus TCP quirks research doc","body":"## Summary\n\nAdds `docs/v2/s7.md` (485 lines) covering Siemens SIMATIC S7 family Modbus TCP behavior. Mirrors the `docs/v2/dl205.md` template for future per-quirk implementation PRs.\n\n## Key findings for the implementation track\n\n- **No fixed memory map** — every S7 Modbus server is user-wired via `MB_SERVER`/`MODBUSCP`/`MODBUSPN` library blocks. Driver must accept per-site config, not assume a vendor layout.\n- **MB_SERVER requires non-optimized DBs** (STATUS `0x8383` if optimized). Most common field bug.\n- **Word order default = ABCD** (opposite of DL260). Driver's S7 profile default must be `ByteOrder.BigEndian`, not `WordSwap`.\n- **One port per MB_SERVER instance** — multi-client requires parallel FBs on 503/504/… Most clients assume port 502 multiplexes (wrong on S7).\n- **CP 343-1 Lean is server-only**, requires the `2XV9450-1MB00` license.\n- **FC20/21/22/23/43 all return Illegal Function** on every S7 variant — driver must not attempt FC23 bulk-read optimization for S7.\n- **STOP-mode behavior non-deterministic** across firmware bands — treat both read/write STOP-mode responses as unavailable.\n\nTwo items flagged as unconfirmed rumour (V2.0+ float byte-order claim, STOP-mode caching location).\n\nNo code, no tests — implementation lands in PRs 56+.\n\n## Test plan\n- [x] Doc renders as markdown\n- [x] 31 citations present\n- [x] Section structure matches dl205.md template","head":"phase-3-pr54-s7-research-doc","base":"v2"}
{"title":"Phase 3 PR 55 -- Mitsubishi MELSEC Modbus TCP quirks research doc","body":"## Summary\n\nAdds `docs/v2/mitsubishi.md` (451 lines) covering MELSEC Q/L/iQ-R/iQ-F/FX3U Modbus TCP behavior. Mirrors `docs/v2/dl205.md` template for per-quirk implementation PRs.\n\n## Key findings for the implementation track\n\n- **Module naming trap** — `QJ71MB91` is SERIAL RTU, not TCP. TCP module is `QJ71MT91`. Surface clearly in driver docs.\n- **No canonical mapping** — per-site 'Modbus Device Assignment Parameter' block (up to 16 entries). Treat mapping as runtime config.\n- **X/Y hex vs octal depends on family** — Q/L/iQ-R use HEX (X20 = decimal 32); FX/iQ-F use OCTAL (X20 = decimal 16). Helper must take a family selector.\n- **Word order CDAB default** across all MELSEC families (opposite of Siemens S7). Driver Mitsubishi profile default: `ByteOrder.WordSwap`.\n- **D-registers binary by default** (opposite of DL205's BCD default). Caller opts in to `Bcd16`/`Bcd32` when ladder uses BCD.\n- **FX5U needs firmware ≥ 1.060** for Modbus TCP server — older is client-only.\n- **FX3U-ENET vs FX3U-ENET-P502 vs FX3U-ENET-ADP** — only the middle one binds port 502; the last has no Modbus at all. Common operator mis-purchase.\n- **QJ71MT91 does NOT support FC22 / FC23** — iQ-R / iQ-F do. Bulk-read optimization must gate on capability.\n- **STOP-mode writes configurable** on Q/L/iQ-R/iQ-F (default accept), always rejected on FX3U-ENET.\n\nThree unconfirmed rumours flagged separately.\n\nNo code, no tests — implementation lands in PRs 58+.\n\n## Test plan\n- [x] Doc renders as markdown\n- [x] 17 citations present\n- [x] Per-model test naming matrix included (`Mitsubishi_QJ71MT91_*`, `Mitsubishi_FX5U_*`, `Mitsubishi_FX3U_ENET_*`, shared `Mitsubishi_Common_*`)","head":"phase-3-pr55-mitsubishi-research-doc","base":"v2"}
| Discrete Inputs (1x)| FC02 | *implicit* — I process image | `%I0.0`–`%I1023.7` (→ discrete addresses 0–8191) [1][9] |
| Input Registers (3x)| FC04 | *implicit* — M memory or DB (version-dependent) | Some firmware routes FC04 through the same MB_HOLD_REG buffer [1][8] |
| Holding Registers (4x)| FC03, FC06, FC16 | `MB_HOLD_REG` pointer | User DB (e.g. `DB10.DBW0`) or `%MW` area [1][2][8] |
- **`MB_HOLD_REG` is a pointer (VARIANT / ANY) into a user-defined DB** whose
first byte is holding-register 0 (`40001` in 1-based Modicon form). Byte
offset 2 is register 1, byte offset 4 is register 2, etc. [1][2].
- **The DB *must* have "Optimized block access" UNCHECKED.** Optimized DBs let
the compiler reorder fields for alignment; Modbus requires fixed byte
offsets. With optimized access on, the compiler accepts the project but
`MB_SERVER` returns STATUS `0x8383` (misaligned access) or silently reads
zeros [8][10][11]. This is the #1 support-forum complaint.
- **FC01/FC02/FC05/FC15 hit the Q and I process images directly — not the
- **CP 443-1 in S7-400H**: uses `MODBUSCP_REDUNDANT` which presents two
Ethernet endpoints that fail over. Our driver's redundancy support should
recognize the S7-400H profile as "two IP addresses, same server state,
advertise via `ServerUriArray`" [6].
- **ET 200SP CPU (1510SP / 1512SP)**: behaves as S7-1500 from `MB_SERVER`
perspective. No known deltas [3].
## References
1. Siemens Industry Online Support, *Modbus/TCP Communication between SIMATIC S7-1500 / S7-1200 and Modbus/TCP Controllers with Instructions `MB_CLIENT` and `MB_SERVER`*, Entry ID 102020340, V6 (Feb 2021). https://cache.industry.siemens.com/dl/files/340/102020340/att_118119/v6/net_modbus_tcp_s7-1500_s7-1200_en.pdf
2. Siemens TIA Portal Online Docs, *MB_SERVER instruction*. https://docs.tia.siemens.cloud/r/simatic_s7_1200_manual_collection_eses_20/communication-processor-and-modbus-tcp/modbus-communication/modbus-tcp/modbus-tcp-instructions/mb_server-communicate-using-profinet-as-modbus-tcp-server-instruction
3. Siemens, *SIMATIC S7-1500 Communication Function Manual* (covers ET 200SP CPU). http://public.eandm.com/Public_Docs/s71500_communication_function_manual_en-US_en-US.pdf
4. Siemens Industry Online Support, *SIMATIC Modbus/TCP communication using CP 343-1 and CP 443-1 — Programming Manual*, Entry ID 103447617. https://cache.industry.siemens.com/dl/files/617/103447617/att_106971/v1/simatic_modbus_tcp_cp_en-US_en-US.pdf
5. Siemens Industry Online Support FAQ *"Which technical data applies for the SIMATIC Modbus/TCP software for CP 343-1 / CP 443-1?"*, Entry ID 104946406. https://www.industry-mobile-support.siemens-info.com/en/article/detail/104946406
6. Siemens Industry Online Support, *Redundant Modbus/TCP communication via CP 443-1 in S7-400H systems*, Entry ID 109739212. https://cache.industry.siemens.com/dl/files/212/109739212/att_887886/v1/SIMATIC_modbus_tcp_cp_red_e_en-US.pdf
7. Siemens Industry Online Support, *SIMATIC MODBUS (TCP) PN CPU Library — Programming and Operating Manual 06/2014*, Entry ID 75330636. https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/attachments/75330636/ModbusTCPPNCPUen.pdf
8. DMC Inc., *Using an S7-1200 PLC as a Modbus TCP Slave*. https://www.dmcinfo.com/blog/27313/using-an-s7-1200-plc-as-a-modbus-tcp-slave/
10. lamaPLC, *Simatic Modbus S7 error- and statuscodes*. https://www.lamaplc.com/doku.php?id=simatic:errorcodes
11. ScadaProtocols, *How to Configure Modbus TCP on Siemens S7-1200 (TIA Portal Step-by-Step)*. https://scadaprotocols.com/modbus-tcp-siemens-s7-1200-tia-portal/
12. Industrial Monitor Direct, *Reading and Writing Memory Bits via Modbus TCP on S7-1200*. https://industrialmonitordirect.com/blogs/knowledgebase/reading-and-writing-memory-bits-via-modbus-tcp-on-s7-1200
13. PLCtalk forum *"Siemens S7-1200 modbus understanding"*. https://www.plctalk.net/forums/threads/siemens-s7-1200-modbus-understanding.104119/
15. Chipkin, *How Real (Floating Point) and 32-bit Data is Encoded in Modbus*. https://store.chipkin.com/articles/how-real-floating-point-and-32-bit-data-is-encoded-in-modbus-rtu-messages
16. Siemens Industry Online Support forum, *MODBUS DATA conversion in S7-1200 CPU*, Entry ID 97287. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/WW/en/posts/modbus-data-converson-in-s7-1200-cpu/97287
18. Siemens TIA Portal, *Data types in SIMATIC S7-1200/1500 — String/WString header layout* (system manual, "Elementary Data Types").
19. Kepware / PTC, *Siemens TCP/IP Ethernet Driver Help*, "Byte / Word Order" tag property. https://www.opcturkey.com/uploads/siemens-tcp-ip-ethernet-manual.pdf
20. Siemens SiePortal forum, *Transfer float out of words*, Entry ID 187811. https://sieportal.siemens.com/en-ww/support/forum/posts/transfer-float-out-of-words/187811 _(operator-reported "S7 swaps float" claim — traced to remote-device issue; **unconfirmed**.)_
21. Siemens SiePortal forum, *S7-1200 communication with Modbus TCP*, Entry ID 133086. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/WW/en/posts/s7-1200-communication-with-modbus-tcp/133086
22. Siemens SiePortal forum, *S7-1500 MB Server Holding Register Max Word*, Entry ID 224636. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/WW/en/posts/s7-1500-mb-server-holding-register-max-word/224636
23. Siemens, *SIMATIC S7-1500 Technical Specifications* — CPU-specific DB size limits in each CPU manual's "Memory" table.
26. Siemens SiePortal forum, *How many TCP connections can the S7-1200 make?*, Entry ID 275570. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/WW/en/posts/how-many-tcp-connections-can-the-s7-1200-make/275570
27. Siemens SiePortal forum, *Simultaneous connections of Modbus TCP*, Entry ID 189626. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/ww/en/posts/simultaneous-connections-of-modbus-tcp/189626
28. Siemens SiePortal forum, *How many Modbus TCP IP clients can read simultaneously from S7-1517*, Entry ID 261569. https://support.industry.siemens.com/forum/WW/en/posts/how-many-modbus-tcp-ip-client-can-read-simultaneously-in-s7-1517/261569
"_comment":"s7_1500.json -- Siemens SIMATIC S7-1500 + MB_SERVER quirk simulator. Models docs/v2/s7.md behaviors as concrete register values. Unlike DL260 (CDAB word order default) or Mitsubishi (CDAB default), S7 MB_SERVER uses ABCD word order by default because Siemens native CPU types are big-endian top-to-bottom both within the register pair and byte pair. This profile exists so the driver's S7 profile default ByteOrder.BigEndian can be validated end-to-end. pymodbus bit-address semantics are the same as dl205.json (FC01/02/05/15 address X maps to cell index X/16); seed bits at the appropriate cell-indexed positions.",
{"_quirk":"DB1 header marker. On an S7-1500 with MB_SERVER pointing at DB1, operators often reserve DB1.DBW0 for a fingerprint word so clients can verify they're talking to the right DB. 0xABCD = 43981.",
"addr":0,"value":43981},
{"_quirk":"Scratch HR range 200..209 -- mirrors the standard.json scratch range so the smoke test (S7_1500Profile.SmokeHoldingRegister=200) round-trips identically against either profile.",
"addr":200,"value":0},
{"addr":201,"value":0},
{"addr":202,"value":0},
{"addr":203,"value":0},
{"addr":204,"value":0},
{"addr":205,"value":0},
{"addr":206,"value":0},
{"addr":207,"value":0},
{"addr":208,"value":0},
{"addr":209,"value":0},
{"_quirk":"Float32 1.5f in ABCD word order (Siemens big-endian default, OPPOSITE of DL260 CDAB). IEEE-754 1.5 = 0x3FC00000. ABCD = high word first: HR[100]=0x3FC0=16320, HR[101]=0x0000=0.",
"addr":100,"value":16320},
{"_quirk":"Float32 1.5f ABCD low word.",
"addr":101,"value":0},
{"_quirk":"Int32 0x12345678 in ABCD word order. HR[300]=0x1234=4660, HR[301]=0x5678=22136. Demonstrates the contrast with DL260 CDAB Int32 encoding.",
"addr":300,"value":4660},
{"addr":301,"value":22136}
],
"bits":[
{"_quirk":"Coil bank marker cell. S7 MB_SERVER doesn't fix coil addresses; this simulates a user-wired DB where coil 400 (=bit 0 of cell 25) represents a latched digital output. Cell 25 bit 0 = 1 proves the wire-format round-trip works for coils on S7 profile.",
"addr":25,"value":1},
{"_quirk":"Discrete-input bank marker cell. DI 500 (=bit 0 of cell 31) = 1. Like coils, discrete inputs on S7 MB_SERVER are per-site; we assert the end-to-end FC02 path only.",
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.