QuestDB Start/End/Delta reads of a tag being written intermittently failed
BadHistoryOperationUnsupported (InvalidCastException: Column 'ts_3' is null):
the StartEnd query referenced its CTE four times and QuestDB opens a table
reader per reference, so a row committed between two of them was counted but
not picked. MinimumActualTime/MaximumActualTime had the same race and returned
a value-less Good.
(a) SQL
- QuestDB StartEnd: one scan, one GROUP BY — first()/last() for the
any-quality picks, arg_min/arg_max keyed on the usable rows' time for the
usable picks (no str_value: arg_min has no VARCHAR form; only Delta reads
them). Byte-identical output to the old query on a 1M-row tag, ~15% faster.
- SqlServer StartEnd: one windowed pass + conditional MAX (was five CTE
references); identical output, 1.4-3x faster.
- ActualTime kept on both backends: every single-scan form measured 1.2-2.4x
slower; its inconsistency is absorbed by (b).
(b) Defence in depth on both backends
- ReadBucket takes DbDataReader and reads absent picks as null
(ReadStoredOrNull) instead of throwing.
- AggregateEvaluator: Delta with a missing first/last usable pick and
ActualTime with a missing extreme are BadNoData (were BadAggregateInvalidInputs
/ a value-less Good); Start/End with no pick already were.
- Unit tests (Sql.Common evaluator, QuestDb + SqlServer mappers over a
DataTableReader) fail with the guards removed.
LiveWriteReadRaceStressTests (QuestDB integration, opt-in via
HISTORIAN_QUESTDB_STRESS_SECONDS, Category=SlowUnit): single-row writer vs
4 tight-loop readers. Old code: 6 faults in ~105k reads; new: 0 in 106k.
Docs: Historian.md QuestDB processed-read note; F2 (Min/Max on the interval
start: SDK raw, ours Calculated) and F3 (integer tags: SDK casts interpolated
values to the integer type, ours Double) added to the SDK-parity deviations.
Per-sample aggregates (all but Average) now set Partial on a reverse read's interval
that strictly contains the tag's latest sample — the SDK's reverse m_startOfData
(verified vs the SDK harness), matching lane A's time-weighted rule. NeedsDataRange
therefore applies in both directions for every per-sample aggregate but Average.
PercentGood/Bad left the per-sample evaluator (lane A moved them to the time-weighted
family); Evaluate refuses non-per-sample aggregates up front. Comments fixed.
Count: Good samples only, value-based status (all Bad => generic Bad), 0/Good on an
empty interval inside the tag's data range [first, last] (both directions).
Start/End: the raw first/last sample of any quality (own value, status, timestamp).
Delta: Uncertain only when the interval's first or last sample is not usable.
Forward end-of-data Partial (SDK m_endOfData, earlier edge inclusive) for every
per-sample aggregate but Average (PercentGood/Bad left to lane A).
Backends push down first/last-any-quality columns and fetch the tag's data range
(earliest <= window end, latest >= window start) only when NeedsDataRange.
SDK parity masks for Start/End/Delta/Count removed; new parity datasets.
F1: the SDK applies its m_startOfData Partial rule to forward reads only; ours
now does too (AggregateEvaluator.EvaluateAll + TimeWeightedAggregator). New
reverse late-start parity tests through the SDK oracle (unit) and real SQL
(conformance, both backends).
F2: AggregateEvaluator.NeedsEarliestSample — the earliest-sample query runs
only for forward reads of aggregates other than Average, and is bounded by
the window end (SqlServer < @end, QuestDB ts < $2).
F3: per-sample SDK parity extended to Range, Start, End, Delta, Min/Max
ActualTime and PercentGood/Bad (oracle maps StatusAggregateCalculator);
pre-existing definitional differences masked and marked #680.
Docs: Historian.md Partial/SDK-parity sections, CLAUDE.md bullet.
- IHistorianDataSource.SupportsReverseEvents (default false; SqlServer/QuestDB true; Gateway/Null declare false).
The node manager checks it BEFORE calling the source: an end-only capped events read becomes reverse only on
a supporting backend (Gateway, the default, keeps the pre-#675 forward [MinValue, EndTime) paging), and an
explicit reverse read on a non-supporting backend is BadHistoryOperationUnsupported without a call.
- Removed the broad catch (NotSupportedException) in the events path: a NotSupportedException from inside a
backend is now logged as a backend fault (Error), not an 'unsupported' Warning.
- Null declares the reverse overload itself; guard test: every production IHistorianDataSource declares both
the reverse overload and the capability (positive-control scan of all four backends).
- Conformance: capability reported + oversized reverse tie cluster (forward over-fetch reversed == reverse
read order; capped reverse read stopping inside the cluster flags truncation) on SqlServer + QuestDB.
- docs/Historian.md: end-only capped events read is backward on SqlServer/QuestDB, forward on Gateway.
- BucketPlan: reverse processed reads anchored at the later time for every
aggregate: window (end, start], partial interval earliest, results stamped
with the later edge, latest first (SDK CreateSlice/GetTimestamp/backward
GetValues). SqlServer adds @bucketAdjustTicks + flips the window predicate;
QuestDB binds BucketBaseUnixTicks. IndexOf is the C# statement of the math.
- Partial bit on the interval the tag's data starts inside (SDK m_startOfData),
every aggregate but Average; per-sample reads fetch the earliest sample.
- Node manager: non-default client AggregateConfiguration =>
BadAggregateConfigurationRejected per node (ServerAggregateConfiguration,
pinned to the SDK AggregateManager defaults).
- GatewayTagProvisioner sends IntegralDivisor = 1.
- SDK parity oracle (Opc.Ua.Server calculators) in unit + both backends'
conformance suites, forward and reverse; remaining divergences documented.
- docs/Historian.md + CLAUDE.md release note (client-visible).
- IHistorianDataSource.ReadEventsAsync(..., bool reverse, ...) overload: reverse = Part 11 window (lo, hi]
newest-first by (time, id) DESC. Default forwards forward reads and throws NotSupportedException for
reverse (Null); Gateway refuses explicitly (ascending-only stream). Server answers
BadHistoryOperationUnsupported instead of silently returning the earliest N ascending.
- SqlServer / QuestDB serve reverse natively (ORDER BY time DESC, id DESC + TOP/LIMIT).
- Node manager: reverse event reads page with continuation points; direction stored in the cursor
(HistoryContinuationState.Reverse) so a resume continues in the cursor's direction; reverse tie clusters
over-fetched forward and sliced from the newest end (SliceTieCluster(reverse:)); end-only reads with a
cap page backward from EndTime (mirrors raw).
- Resumed event pages over-fetch by the boundary skip, so every non-final page is a full cap page.
- Tests: node-manager reverse paging (ties, clusters, coarse resolution, overfetch bound, resume
direction both ways, end-only, unsupported backend); shared EventReadConformance on SqlServer +
QuestDB; over-the-wire reverse paging; offline Gateway pin of the UTC DateTime.MaxValue bound through
the published client's proto conversion (in-process gRPC capture) and FILETIME.
- docs/Historian.md event paging section.
- HistoryModifiedValue gains explicit SourceTimeUtc (SqlServer + QuestDB populate it); the node manager's resume cursor uses it instead of the prior value's nullable source timestamp (MinValue for inserts).
- ACL test now uses a trail-returning data source and asserts Good + data on the allow leg.
- Node-manager tests: end-only backward open-ended paging, reverse resume cursor, null-prior cursor.
- QuestDB updater logs a Warning (tag + time range) when a sample write fails after its trail rows landed.
- docs/Historian.md: rolling-upgrade window, IDENTITY-vs-commit ordering, QuestDB cross-node ModifiedId clock ordering.
Every HistoryUpdate a SQL backend applies now leaves a modification trail
(prior value, principal, Part 11 update type, modification time), and
HistoryReadRaw with IsReadModified=true serves it as HistoryModifiedData.
- Core: HistoryUpdateContext threaded into all three IHistorianDataUpdater
methods; IHistorianDataSource.ReadModifiedAsync (default NotSupported =>
BadHistoryOperationUnsupported on Gateway/Null); HistoryModified* contracts.
- SqlServer: schema v2 (002_sample_modified.sql, RequiredVersion=2, docs copy);
trail written by OUTPUT ... INTO on the same MERGE/DELETE statement, so a
failed update leaves no audit row; retention purges SampleModified per tag on
the source-time cutoff; ReadModifiedAsync keyed on (SourceTimeUtc, ModifiedId).
- QuestDB: append-only {prefix}sample_modified (TTL like samples), trail row
written BEFORE the change (orphan-on-crash, never an untracked change);
existence reads now carry the prior value; ReadModifiedAsync.
- Node manager: modified reads dispatch + page via the #669 continuation store
(HistoryContinuationState gains HistoryCursorKind + LastModifiedId), gated by
the existing HistoryRead decision; session principal / key id passed to the
updater. IsDeleteModified stays unsupported.
- Client.CLI: historyread --modified.
- Tests: node-manager dispatch/paging/cursor binding/principal threading,
over-the-wire HistoryModifiedData, shared ModifiedValueConformance on both
backends, SqlServer atomicity (forced trail failure => no change) + v1->v2
upgrade + retention trail purge.
- Docs: Historian.md (Modified-value history section, schema v2 upgrade note),
security.md, Client.CLI.md, CLAUDE.md.
M1: the time-weighted family (incl. Total, formerly a pushed-down SUM) streams
raw window rows into the C# evaluator. New shared knob
ServerHistorian:MaxTimeWeightedRawRows (default 1,000,000; <=0 unbounded with a
Validate warning) flows through HistorianBackendRegistry into both providers.
The window query is capped at cap+1 (SQL Server TOP (@maxRows), QuestDB LIMIT $4);
one row past the cap throws the new Core.Abstractions
HistoryReadLimitExceededException, which the node manager maps to
BadTooManyOperations for that node. Not counted as a backend health failure;
bound rows are not counted; per-sample aggregates are not capped.
M2: reverse Interpolative is anchored at the later time (Part 13): points at
End - i*interval, emitted latest first. 10:00->09:00 @1h yields 10:00.
L1: Partial bit (0x4, = Opc.Ua.AggregateBits.Partial) on non-Bad results of a
truncated last interval (time-weighted family; per-sample family is a follow-up).
L2/L3: aligned with the SDK AggregateCalculator.GetTimeBasedStatusCode
(decompiled from Opc.Ua.Server 1.5.378.106): TreatUncertainAsBad=false counts
Uncertain time (Uncertain samples, held-into-outage, extrapolation) as Good
time; data but no non-Bad time => generic Bad (0x80000000); BadNoData only
when there is no data at all. Consequence: a live tag's latest interval reads
Good (documented).
L5: release note no longer claims Total matches the Gateway Integral exactly
(AVEVA's divisor is unverified); it notes Total is now evaluated in C# and
subject to the cap.
Tests: unit (reverse Interpolative x3, Partial, Bad vs BadNoData incl. an
open-ended outage, cap helpers, SDK bit oracles); conformance (reverse
Interpolative, raw-row cap at/over/0, bounds not counted, health unaffected);
node manager BadTooManyOperations; options default + warning. Each new
behaviour falsified by mutation (aggregator x9, data-source cap checks on
both backends against the real DBs, node-manager catch).
New AggregateFamily.TimeWeighted serving TimeAverage, TimeAverage2, Total,
Total2 and Interpolative, evaluated by the shared Sql.Common
TimeWeightedAggregator for both SQL backends (identical results by
construction). HistoryAggregateType gains TimeAverage2 + Total2 (appended);
OtOpcUaNodeManager.MapAggregate maps their NodeIds. Gateway's mapper already
refuses unknown defined members => BadAggregateNotSupported per node.
Semantics (server defaults, client AggregateConfiguration ignored):
TreatUncertainAsBad=false, PercentDataBad=PercentDataGood=100,
UseSlopedExtrapolation=false. Sloped for Double/Int64, stepped for Boolean;
a usable sample followed by a Bad one is held up to the outage (AtTime rule);
stepped Uncertain extrapolation past the last sample. TimeAverage/Total use
interpolated bounding (bridge outages); TimeAverage2/Total2 exclude Bad time.
Bounding values: latest usable + latest any before start, first any + first
usable at/after end (four TOP 1 / LIMIT 1 seeks).
CLIENT-VISIBLE: Total on SqlServer/QuestDb was SUM of samples; it is now the
time-weighted integral (TimeAverage x interval seconds), matching Gateway's
Integral. Release note in docs/Historian.md.
Trade-off (deviation from the preferred hybrid pushdown, allowed by the
design): the time-weighted family is NOT pushed down. Each read streams the
window's rows plus the four bounds (SQL Server: one five-result-set batch;
QuestDB: bounds UNION ALL + window select) into the C# evaluator. Network is
O(samples in window), memory O(buckets). Writing the per-segment
interpolation/edge splitting twice in two SQL dialects and keeping them
bit-identical was judged the bigger risk; this also makes the QuestDB
lag/lead spike moot.
Tests: 35 hand-computed TimeWeightedAggregator unit cases (each of 10
implementation mutations goes red); served-aggregate pin 13 -> 17;
conformance sparse fixture (intervals wider and narrower than sample gaps)
+ an outage straddling both window edges (each of the four SQL seeks
disabled in turn goes red); node-manager NodeId mapping test.
- I-1: QuestDbConnection caps Npgsql Maximum Pool Size at 24 (DefaultMaxPoolSize)
when the connection string does not set it; an explicit value is kept. The
effective value is logged once at Information.
- M-1: QuestDbTagCatalog.EnsureAsync waits for the tag table's sequenced commits
and re-checks before inserting, so it no longer overwrites a provisioner row
(unit/description) that is committed but not yet applied. Integration test
reproduces the clobber against real QuestDB (falsified).
- M-3: the pre-1970 drop Warning is rate-limited per tag (once per 10 min);
DroppedPre1970 still counts every sample.
- M-5: QuestDbHistorianProvider is IAsyncDisposable/IDisposable and disposes the
shared Npgsql pool; Program.cs registers the provider through a factory and
every seam resolves it from the container, so DI disposes it at shutdown.
- M-8, M-9: docs fixes (HistoryUpdate transaction wording; folded duplicate
HistoryUpdate paragraph). Pool-size docs updated for the new default cap.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ef2ozxS7QPanGT8uoATbTe
IHistorianDataSource.TimestampResolutionTicks (default 1; QuestDB 10). A drained tie
cluster now steps off T by the resolution, so a forward one-value-per-page read on a
microsecond backend no longer re-reads the same sample forever (C1). QuestDB AtTime
results carry the client's original request time (M3); regression for the NEXT seek
skipping a tombstone (M1). Conformance backend wires the real writer and updater.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ef2ozxS7QPanGT8uoATbTe
QuestDbHistorianDataSource serves Raw (LIMIT $n, no continuation, R8), AtTime
(chunked LIMIT 1 neighbour seeks, <=50 times per statement), Events and
Processed (one statement per node, bucket = (cast(ts AS LONG)*10 - start)/interval,
shared BucketPlan/AggregateEvaluator/AtTimeEvaluator). Every sample read filters
NOT deleted; every row goes through StoredSample.FromStored; RC2 long.MinValue
read repair. QuestDbConformanceBackend (seed/read-back) for the conformance suite;
writer/updater factories are T7 placeholders.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ef2ozxS7QPanGT8uoATbTe
Joseph Doherty