Files
scadaproj/components/ui-theme/validation/theme-1.0.1/review.md
T

6.0 KiB

Independent Theme 1.0.1 source/provenance review

Reviewed 2026-11-13; source/provenance only. No publish, gate/ledger update, extra suite execution or candidate browser claim.

Superseded first candidate

This candidate was not published and is superseded by the source amendment below. Its hashes describe only the earlier reviewed bytes, not the final 1.0.1 delivery.

No concrete source or artifact blocker found in that first candidate. Source commit 5d2d9530bad0d0afd3821ecc3469312fddd04395 changes canonical card-grid minimum to minmax(min(290px,100%),1fr), package version and supporting README/decision/before evidence. The CSS diff is exactly one declaration: it bounds the minimum by available width while preserving 290px minimum at normal available widths, auto-fill, gap and other geometry. No colors, component API, role or domain behavior changed. Actual narrow-host acceptance remains with the parent's candidate browser proof.

Independently rehashed the exact retained artifacts:

  • Nupkg SHA256: 0c3bc699465c935525a77a01ff05f8c4f332a1b3363f5918af61add339babdab.
  • Static export SHA256: fb8b8f549d541e5cf87cf7e752f8aa34ce52bfa08380c217d9ef90ec5323cd5c.

Verified exact export file set, all six payload hashes, package hash in manifest, nuspec 1.0.1 and repository commit. All five CSS/font payloads equal both nupkg entries and git show of the stated commit byte for byte. Compared token dictionaries against retained 1.0.0 export: all 47 values are identical; only version/provenance metadata changes. Earlier 1.0.0 artifact history remains intact.

Actual Theme TRX records 105/105 executed/passed, zero failed/notExecuted. Exporter log records 15 passing tests. Build log records zero warnings/errors. These observed logs substantiate the reported source checks; they do not replace runtime reflow acceptance or independent published-feed download/restore. Consumer adoption must wait for the final rebuilt candidate and delivery handoff; these superseded hashes must not be used for that adoption. No local grid workaround is warranted.

Source amendment reviewed: 075cf47

Reviewed the exact new source commit 075cf47fc2bbdb42c98e17d9eaa99275a7e1b95c. The additional executable CSS delta is solely @media (max-width: 319px) { .agg-grid { grid-template-columns: 1fr; } }. It follows the existing 620px two-column rule, so the existing aggregate strip becomes one column only below 320px; wider breakpoint behavior, colors, typography and component APIs remain unchanged. This addresses the parent's observed 195px effective-viewport KPI overflow, independently of the earlier card-grid correction. No concrete source blocker found in this delta.

The rebuilt nupkg/export, pinned commit, payload hashes and runtime confirmation for this amended candidate are pending the parent's exact handoff at the time of this amendment. Earlier artifact checks above cannot establish provenance of rebuilt bytes. Version 1.0.1 remains unpublished; no gate or publication claim is made here. Root owns the actual Overview reflow/zoom matrix and local long-diagnostic domain wrapping.

Final source amendment reviewed: d8d633d

Reviewed d8d633ddb21f899bab1c958b0c62f55a98ef6d27. Its sole executable delta narrows the special header rule to .data-table th:not([scope="row"]). Existing common th/td padding, borders, alignment and nowrap rules are unchanged. Semantic row headers consequently avoid the column-header-only uppercase/faint/sticky treatment; legacy unscoped and explicit column headers continue to match. No concrete source blocker found. This source amendment supersedes 075cf47 as final candidate provenance; version 1.0.1 is still unpublished. Rebuilt artifact verification and the parent's computed row/column browser proof must reference this new exact commit; no prior candidate hash is carried forward as if it proved these bytes.

Final rebuilt candidate and recorded runtime proof

Independently verified the final d8d633ddb21f899bab1c958b0c62f55a98ef6d27 artifacts, superseding all earlier candidate hashes:

  • Nupkg SHA256: 995b117b0245577598c91404ed7957c071ebe3413696c8be48b419c9deb1bd5d.
  • Static export SHA256: ad52323416e5096e30e4b7624004274689bc2b72e1437f9e9e5d7db9f9e656e0.

Recomputed both hashes; verified exact export file set, every payload hash, manifest package/source metadata, nuspec version/commit and all five CSS/font bytes against both package and final git object. All 47 token values still equal retained 1.0.0. Recorded served CSS SHA 7a6da7aefcf036f971f18816e3ceb129f1abb4a39f6db33d449420b814cfb4a6 independently equals the exact package CSS. actual-runtime.json records assembly 1.0.1.0 and semantic row header position static, normal case, body size/ink; explicit and legacy column headers retain sticky uppercase styling, with equal common padding.

Reviewed the parent's actual Overview browser-confirmation JSON: all 31 measurements have document scroll equal viewport width; page error list is empty. The real 200% case records720px/DPR2. Nine recorded functional outcomes cover filtering/full totals, clear focus, pause aging/held snapshot/resume latest, keyboard disclosure/escaped full diagnostics and reduced motion; three motion samples have opacity1/animation none. Raw descendant-rectangle flags are not universally empty: expanded evidence contains offscreen bold “members” descendants, so this review does not claim every descendant rectangle lies within the viewport. The supported claim is bounded document/card-grid layout with locally accessible evidence, not blanket empty element-overflow lists. Source labels use escaped values in that evidence markup. Actual Theme TRX remains105 passed with no failures/skips; exporter log records15 passing checks. No concrete final source/artifact blocker found in this reviewed scope.

This reviews exact bytes and retained runtime evidence, not fresh browser execution or fleet-wide consumer acceptance. Publication, independent delivered downloads and official-feed restore still require the parent's delivery record. No gate/ledger is changed here.