ReleaseProbe recognised its own reservation by comparing NextProbeAtTicks to
now + _probeIntervalTicks. RecordInto's rearm-on-trip writes that identical
expression, so a concurrent RecordFailure on the same WindowState whose `now`
lands on the claimer's tick — routine at ~1 ms clock resolution under load — was
mistaken for the caller's own claim. The release then stomped the legitimate
fresh re-arm back to the stale previousProbeAtTicks, which is already due, handing
the next arrival a free probe the re-arm had just closed.
WindowState gains a monotonic ProbeVersion bumped by every writer of
NextProbeAtTicks (TryConsumeProbe's claim and RecordInto's re-arm alike).
TryConsumeProbe returns the stamp it set as part of a ProbeClaim; ReleaseProbe
restores the previous value only while the state's version still equals that
stamp, checking and restoring in one lock(state) section and bumping the version
again on restore so no other stale release can match either.
Test: ProbeSlotRestore_DoesNotStompConcurrentRearmAtSameTick, with the clock held
still so the claim and the interleaved failure necessarily share a tick. Making it
deterministic needed a seam — the claim-to-release window is a few nanoseconds and
racing threads do not hit it (an earlier thread-based attempt passed against the
defective guard three runs out of three, and its end state was ordering-dependent
rather than correctness-dependent, so it was dropped rather than shipped as
theatre). The seam is an internal ProbeReleaseInterleaveHook, null in production,
costing one null check on the already-refused path. Verified as a genuine red
against the timestamp guard: Expected ThrottledByPeer, Actual ProbeAdmitted.
All five client CLIs now share one credential contract for `authenticate-user`:
flags `--password` / `--password-env` (Go: `-password` / `-password-env`) with
default env `MXGATEWAY_VERIFY_PASSWORD`, resolution flag-then-env, and a resolved
credential that is missing *or empty* is a usage error naming the flag and the
variable. The value is never echoed and never reaches the wire.
Go and Java previously sent an empty credential when the variable was unset,
turning a misconfigured environment into a real MXAccess authentication attempt.
Go now returns the guard error before dialing; Java throws a picocli
ParameterException instead of falling back to "". Python's `--password-env`
gained the canonical default and its UsageError names the resolved variable.
Rust treats an empty flag or env value as missing, with the resolution extracted
into a testable `resolve_verify_user_password`. .NET adopts the canonical flags
and keeps `--verify-user-password`, `--verify-user-password-env`, and
MXGATEWAY_VERIFY_USER_PASSWORD as deprecated aliases for one release.
Docs same commit: CrossLanguageSmokeMatrix.md gains the credential contract and
the per-CLI subcommand-coverage table (the documented-not-fixed half of the
finding); all five READMEs name the canonical variable and the fail-fast rule,
and the .NET README carries the deprecation note. Tracking flipped to Done in
both remediation registers with a change-log row.
No .proto changed; no generated code regenerated.
One cross-client conformance pass; also closes first-cycle CLI-08.
CLI-37: an MxStatusProxy entry is a failure iff `category !=
MX_STATUS_CATEGORY_OK`. The proto contract has always said so — `success` is
the raw 16-bit COM member carried verbatim for diagnostics, not a boolean — but
four clients branched on `success` alone and .NET required both, so the same
gateway reply produced opposite verdicts per language. An absent entry stays
success; a present entry with an UNSPECIFIED category is a failure, because the
worker always maps a category and an unmapped one is not proven OK.
CLI-38: a reply fails on HRESULT iff `hresult` is present and negative, so
positive COM success codes such as S_FALSE (1) pass. .NET/Go/Java used `!= 0`,
which errored on a parity-preserving S_FALSE that Python and Rust accepted.
This makes the existing ClientLibrariesDesign.md claim true rather than
rewriting the doc to describe the divergence.
Four shared fixtures pin both rules cross-client, and each language suite also
carries a table test for the two edges a fixture cannot express (absent entry,
UNSPECIFIED category). A Java test fake that built a status with a bare
`setSuccess(1)` and no category is fixed — under the category rule that reply
was never a success.
Code-review follow-up on fix/gwc-26-27-alarm-attach.
ApplyReconcile's snapshot-derived feed repairs are at-least-once, not
exactly-once: a reconcile reads the worker's current state while the matching
live transition may still be buffered in the monitor's lease, so both broadcast
and the duplicates are indistinguishable on the alarm feed. This pre-dates the
acked-state delta — the Raise/Clear presence repair has always had it, since
nothing serializes a reconcile pass against the in-flight live stream — so
closing it (serialization or timestamp dedup) stays out of scope for a P2 fix.
Documented instead, with the consumer contract stated explicitly (apply
transitions idempotently, never as an increment or toggle):
- ApplyReconcile gains a "Delivery semantics" comment.
- gateway.md softens the "defense in depth" prose to state the semantics.
- docs/Sessions.md carries the same caveat on the alarm-feed description.
- Tracker change-log records it as a known pre-existing characteristic and a
candidate finding for the next review cycle.
Also hoists the ChannelWorkerClient fake — duplicated across the three alarm
test files — into TestSupport/, dropping the usings it took with it.
Two defects found in code review of the limiter rework.
Probe admission was check-then-act across two lock scopes: Check() read
"probe due" under lock(state), released it, then re-acquired to advance
NextProbeAtTicks. A burst of requests arriving together at an interval boundary
could therefore all observe the slot as due and all be admitted, handing the
verifier the very burst the interval exists to bound. The claim is now a single
critical section (TryConsumeProbe). The two layers are still claimed one at a
time — holding two per-state locks at once would need a global lock ordering to
stay deadlock-free — so a slot claimed on the composite partition is compensated
via ReleaseProbe when the aggregate then refuses, which otherwise silently spent
the partition's next slot and pushed the legitimate holder out by a full
interval.
Reset() removed whatever partition the caller resolved to, including the
address's shared fallback partition when the caller's key id had been collapsed
into it by the per-peer cap (or when the token was junk-shaped). That bucket also
carries failures contributed by other key ids from the same address, so one
successful authentication became a reset button for an in-progress spray. Reset
now clears only a partition the caller owns (effectiveKeyId == presented key id);
the shared bucket decays by window expiry instead, and the caller still recovers
through probe admission. The key's aggregate is cleared either way, as designed.
Also applied from the review: closure-free GetOrAdd overload on _partitions, and
a remarks paragraph acknowledging the best-effort O(n) eviction scan under
sustained overflow. Threading the resolved partition key from Check through to
RecordFailure/Reset was declined: Check resolves with mint:false and RecordFailure
with mint:true, and the two can legitimately differ when a concurrent caller fills
the per-peer cap in between — reusing Check's key would record into the wrong
partition and bypass the cap, which is not worth saving one string concat.
Tests (limiter suite 11 -> 14): ProbeAdmission_UnderConcurrentArrivals_
GrantsExactlyOneSlot (200 rounds x 8 barrier-released threads at the boundary),
ProbeAdmission_WhenAggregateRefuses_ReturnsTheClaimedPeerSlot, and
Reset_WithOverCapKeyId_DoesNotClearSharedFallbackPartition. The latter two were
confirmed as genuine reds against the unfixed code; the concurrency test is a
guard — it is deterministically green on the fixed structure but did not
reproduce the original nanosecond-wide window on its own.
An empty replay ring reported oldest_available_sequence = 0 even when gap was
true. Clients follow the documented after_worker_sequence = oldest - 1 formula,
so an unsigned client computed ulong.MaxValue: the follow-up resume replayed
nothing, reported no gap, and the live filter dropped every subsequent event —
a silently dead stream in the headline detach-and-resume scenario, reachable on
default config once ReplayRetentionSeconds (300) age-evicts the ring.
GWC-25: SessionEventDistributor.RegisterWithReplay's empty-ring branch now
reports _highestSequenceSeen + 1 — the next sequence that can possibly be
delivered — when gap is true, so oldest - 1 lands exactly on the highest
observed sequence and the resume delivers everything newer. Still 0 when there
is no gap, where the field is meaningless and never emitted. Nothing is lost:
the evicted interval was unrecoverable either way, and the sentinel's job is to
say "re-snapshot".
CLI-35: the Python CLI fed every stream item into MessageToDict, which raised on
the ReplayGap dataclass and aborted the command after consuming the stream. A
new _event_row helper renders a gap as {"replayGap": {...}} — the same camelCase
shape the Rust CLI emits — and leaves proto events on the existing path.
CLI-36: the Go CLI formatted result.Event on every row, but the library
deliberately clears Event on a gap, so text mode printed
"0 MX_EVENT_FAMILY_UNSPECIFIED" and JSON mode an empty object, discarding the
resume cursors. The loop now branches on result.IsReplayGap() and renders the
typed row in both modes, counting it toward -limit like any other row. The JSON
row's cursors are typed by hand rather than marshalled with protojson: the
proto3 JSON mapping renders 64-bit integers as strings ("7") while the Rust and
Python CLIs emit numbers (7), so going through protojson would have made Go the
only canonical CLI with a different value type.
Docs in the same change: docs/Sessions.md documents the empty-ring sentinel
value and that oldest - 1 is the universal resume formula in both the retained
and fully-evicted cases; docs/CrossLanguageSmokeMatrix.md gains a per-CLI
gap-rendering table covering both client findings, and records exactly what is
and is not comparable across CLIs (same keys and numeric cursors for Rust/Go/
Python; quoted cursors for .NET/Java; differing key order, whitespace, and
container), so a matrix runner compares parsed values rather than raw bytes.
Tests, all written red first and each reproducing its defect verbatim:
- SessionEventDistributorTests: RegisterWithReplayReportsNextDeliverableSequence
WhenRingEmptiedByAge, ...WithRetentionDisabled, and
ResumeUsingSentinelFormulaAfterEmptyRingGapDeliversLiveEvents.
- GatewayEndToEndReconnectReplayTests.ReconnectAfterFullAgeEvictionResumesWith
SentinelFormula — fake-worker e2e resume walk on a fake clock; the fixture now
takes a retention window and a TimeProvider.
- clients/python test_stream_events_renders_replay_gap.
- clients/go TestRunStreamEventsPrintsReplayGap.
GWC-25's ReplayGap.oldest_available_sequence proto-comment amendment is
deliberately deferred to the later codegen wave (see the tracker change log): it
is comment-only but triggers the full five-client regen fan-out.
RunMonitorAsync issued SubscribeAlarms and the first reconcile before the
internal distributor subscriber was attached (via ISessionManager
.ReadAlarmEventsAsync). The pump has been running since MarkReady started the
dashboard mirror and only fans to subscribers registered at fan-out time, so
every transition raised in that two-round-trip window bypassed the alarm feed —
and a missed Acknowledge was never repaired, because ApplyReconcile broadcast
presence deltas only.
- The monitor now takes the internal lease directly from its session BEFORE
SubscribeAlarms and drains it after the first reconcile; window transitions
buffer in the lease's bounded channel. Processing them after ApplyReconcile is
order-safe (ApplyTransition handles alarms the snapshot already placed).
- ISessionManager.ReadAlarmEventsAsync removed — zero remaining callers.
- ApplyReconcile broadcasts an Acknowledge feed transition when a both-present
alarm's state advanced to ActiveAcked. This is a feed-level repair on the
AlarmFeedMessage/StreamAlarms surface rebuilt from the worker's own snapshot,
not MxEvent emission, so the "never synthesize events" rule is untouched;
the reasoning is recorded on ApplyReconcile.
The alarm-monitor test fakes now hand the monitor a real Ready GatewaySession
with a dashboard mirror, which is what makes the window reproducible.
Docs: docs/Sessions.md and gateway.md alarm-monitor ordering notes.
Refs: archreview/2026-07-12/remediation/10-gateway-core.md GWC-26
The gRPC auth failure limiter partitioned on the key id parsed out of the
*unauthenticated* token and rejected with ResourceExhausted before VerifyAsync
ran. Key ids are not secret — they ride in every token and are listed on the
dashboard — so any network peer could send 10 garbage-secret requests per minute
and deny that key indefinitely: the legitimate holder's correct secret was
refused before it was ever checked, and the success-path Reset that would clear
the block sat behind the verification the block prevented (SEC-31). The tracked
map was also flushable — any `a_b_c`-shaped junk minted a fresh partition (the
`mxgw` literal was never compared), so ~4096 throwaway tokens evicted a blocked
entry and reset the window (SEC-32).
ApiKeyFailureLimiter moves from IsBlocked/RecordFailure/Reset(string peer) to a
partition-pair API: Check/RecordFailure/Reset(ApiKeyThrottlePartition) with an
ApiKeyThrottleDecision result. Two layers share one sliding window — a composite
(transport peer, key id) partition at ApiKeyFailureLimit, and a per-key-id
aggregate across all peers at the new ApiKeyFailureAggregateLimit (default 30)
that bounds a source-rotating sprayer. An over-limit state is now a valve rather
than a wall: one request per the new ApiKeyFailureProbeIntervalSeconds (default
5) is admitted through to the real verifier, so the correct secret always reaches
the constant-time compare and resets both layers. Guarantees preserved: guessing
stays bounded per window, and the failure path still spends no store read per
attempt.
SEC-32 rides the same change set: the interceptor validates token shape (literal
`mxgw` prefix, >= 3 non-empty `_` segments, key id <= 64 chars) before minting a
key-id partition, each transport peer may mint at most 32 of them before the
overflow collapses onto its fallback partition, and eviction prefers fully
expired windows and never drops an over-limit partition below a 2x transient
overshoot ceiling. Throttled attempts increment mxgateway.auth.throttled, tagged
stage=peer|aggregate only — /metrics is unauthenticated (open SEC-14), so no key
material may appear there.
Docs in the same commit: GatewayConfiguration limiter rows plus the two new keys,
the Authentication hot-path paragraph, the Authorization SEC-11 section, and the
limiter / SecurityOptions XML remarks (the old NAT rationale described the
defective keying). Tracking rows flipped to Done with a change-log entry.
Tests: new ApiKeyFailureLimiterTests (11) covering window pruning, composite vs
aggregate trip points, probe cadence, absolute-block mode, reset across both
layers, junk-spray eviction resistance, the per-peer cap, and expired-window
eviction preference; GatewayGrpcAuthorizationInterceptorTests gains the four
SEC-31 contract tests plus NonMxgwToken_FallsBackToTransportPeerPartition (20
total); GatewayOptionsValidatorTests covers both new keys including 0 as a
supported disable value (66 total).
The GWC-04 remediation decoupled the read loop from event backpressure by
staging events into an unbounded channel, so its TryWrite always succeeded and
the only overflow fault was a single timed WriteAsync exceeding
EventChannelFullModeTimeout. A consumer draining slower than the worker
produces — each individual write still completing inside the window — therefore
grew gateway memory without bound, without a fault, and without a metric: the
queue-depth gauge counted only the bounded consumer channel, so staged events
were invisible.
Bound _eventStaging at 2 x EventChannelCapacity (Wait, single reader/writer, no
synchronous continuations). A rejected staging TryWrite is the sustained
slow-drain signal and faults the client ProtocolViolation with
QueueOverflow("worker-event-staging"), guarded by IsTerminalState() so a
completed channel during shutdown stays a silent drop. SetFaulted is
non-blocking, so the read loop still never awaits behind events. The timed-write
fault is unchanged and still catches the full-stall case earlier.
Move the queue-depth increment from EnqueueWorkerEventAsync to StageWorkerEvent
so the single counter reports total undelivered events (staged + queued); the
decrement at consumer read was already correct. No new configuration key: the
bound is derived, and gateway-side buffering per session is now at most
3 x MxGateway:Events:QueueCapacity. Coordination with still-open GWC-21
(EventChannelFullModeTimeout configurability) remains open and was not blocked
on.
Tests: StagingChannelOverflowFaultsWorkerWithoutWaitingForFullModeTimeout (5-min
full-mode timeout so only the staging bound can fire; asserts an interleaved
command reply still completes) and WorkerEventQueueDepthGaugeCountsStagedEvents.
Docs updated in the same change: GatewayProcessDesign, MxAccessWorkerInstanceDesign,
GatewayConfiguration, Metrics. GWC-24 flipped to Done in both trackers.
Migrate the durable session-resilience governance record (Phase 5
orphan-worker reattach deferred-not-planned, EnableOrphanReattach
does not yet exist, settled Phase-4 Viewer-default decision) from
oldtasks.md into a new "Session-Resilience Epic Scope" entry in
docs/DesignDecisions.md, repoint CLAUDE.md and stillpending.md's
oldtasks.md references to the new home / tasks.json, and git rm
oldtasks.md now that it has no unique content left. Flip TST-29 to
Done in the archreview tracking registers.
The five untracked root docs-review artifacts (MxAccessGateway-docs-*,
MxGatewayClient-docs-*) are absent from this worktree; they must be
deleted from the main working tree separately (gitignored, no repo
impact).
Surfaced during TST-25 acceptance verification: all CI runs on one shared
gitea-runner (maxParallel=1, co-located 10.100.0.35) interleaved with
dohertj2/lmxopcua, and Gitea 1.26 has no run cancel/delete API, so queue
latency is unbounded under cross-repo contention and the runner is a single
point of failure. Design: add a second/labelled runner; document the no-cancel
reality and the run-windev-ci.sh queue-bypass. Low/P2. Roll-ups updated.
Operator bring-up complete and the SSH-driven Windows/x86 CI tier passed
green end-to-end under Gitea Actions run #37: the Linux runner SSHed windev,
checked out the SHA in the isolated C:\build\mxaccessgw-ci clone under lock,
built the x86 Worker and ran Worker.Tests (exit 0); nightly-windev correctly
skipped on the push event. Flip TST-25/TST-26 status rows to Done and record
the bring-up + green-run evidence in the change log.
The `windows`/`live-mxaccess` CI jobs were removed in abb0930 because Gitea
act_runner host-mode on Windows is broken and a runs-on gate with no runner
wedges the queue. This left the entire x86/net48 Worker + Worker.Tests tier
(and the live-MXAccess smoke) unguarded by CI.
Restore it without a native Windows runner: Linux jobs on ubuntu-latest (which
always schedule) SSH to windev (10.100.0.48), fetch+checkout the SHA under test
in an isolated clone C:\build\mxaccessgw-ci, run the x86 build/tests there, and
propagate the remote exit code back — so a Worker regression turns the job red
and an unreachable host fails loud (never stuck).
- scripts/ci/run-windev-ci.sh: Linux driver (key/known-hosts, UTF-16LE base64
EncodedCommand bootstrap, ssh, exit-code passthrough).
- scripts/ci/windev-worker-ci.ps1: windev stage — worktree lock, re-fetch/
checkout under lock, build|test|live modes; PS 5.1-safe, checks $LASTEXITCODE.
- scripts/ci/windev.known_hosts: pinned host keys for StrictHostKeyChecking.
- scripts/ci/README.md: operator bring-up + acceptance checklist.
- ci.yml: windows-x86 (per-push `test`) + nightly-windev (scheduled `live` +
on-failure Gitea issue); drop the removal note; fix header/cron comments.
TST-26 (same commit, by rule): correct docs/scripts that still describe the
removed jobs — GatewayTesting.md, Contracts.md, check-codegen.ps1 — and
reattribute the Generated/-commit guard (primary = check-codegen diff in the
portable job; secondary = windows-x86 net48 compile).
Mechanism hand-verified on windev: build->0, bogus-SHA->nonzero (lock released),
test->356 passed/0 failed in ~50s, ssh exit-code propagation confirmed. Merge
requires operator bring-up first (dedicated ci@ key + Gitea secrets) or the
per-push job is red every push — see scripts/ci/README.md.
Six-domain re-review at the P2 merge (4f5371f): all prior Done claims
verified (none false, 10 partial), 47 new findings (1 High, 14 Medium),
with per-finding design/implementation plans and a new tracking register.
Joseph Doherty