Files
lmxopcua/docs/ui-consistency/evidence/ot14-final/impeccable-final-review.md
T

5.1 KiB
Raw Blame History

Final Impeccable audit and polish disposition

Implementation integrity: pass within the verified candidate scope. The product retains the shared Technical-Light/IBM Plex shell and actual operational vocabulary. No mockup-only metrics/endpoints, alternative palette or copied theme were introduced. Source findings are supported by the retained raw tests/native matrices rather than a detector score alone.

The Impeccable4.3.1 bundled detector ran once on final authored Components/appCSS/appJS, excluding unchanged vendored Bootstrap/Monaco libraries. impeccable-detector.json is [], exit0. The subsequent two host PageTitle metadata lines were manually reviewed and verified in eight targeted real-browser cases; no layout/color/behavior source changed after this scan. Initial source-audit warnings from vendored Bootstrap were not treated as new product defects or silently waived. No project detector-ignore file was added. The context launcher was not rerun.

Dimension Bounded score Evidence and limit
Accessibility 3/4 Actual AX names/ID relationships, keyboard dialogs/trees, text contrast and native invalid/busy/error paths. VoiceOver explicitly excluded by user; no blanket WCAG/AAA certification
Performance 3/4 Real virtualized30/44px rows, bounded mounted rows with800 selections, lazy read/query contracts,200/500 tail caps/coalescing. No production fleet load or general profiling benchmark
Responsive design 3/4 Desktop/phone and actual200%720/195 CSS pixels, local keyboard scrolling, coarse controls and retained parent dialog chrome. Finite content/state/role samples, not every possible configuration
Theming 3/4 Exact Theme1.0.1 CSS/fonts, shared semantic inks, inherited Bootstrap bridge and same neutral/blue shell. OT's supported Technical-Light scope retained; no new dark-mode claim
Implementation integrity 4/4 Shared components/one active overlay, named inline child editors, target-owned callbacks/read recovery and actual domain semantics. Clean authored detector supported by source/native checks
Total 16/20 · Good Engineering judgment over recorded evidence; neither live conformance certification nor the earlier source-review score

Resolved measured defects

The first final admin/cluster matrix had18 failures across five surfaces: missing field names and narrow geometry. Corrections preserve original business bodies; the84case confirmation retained two residual ACL195px failures, closed by exactly two targeted cases. A final coverage check caught the checker’s Account/Secrets title exemption; both host pages now set meaningful product-qualified titles and eight targeted cases pass. Raw exclusions/before values remain recorded rather than rewriting the earlier coverage claim.

Stale status opacity composed approved inks to failing contrast. The narrow panel fix removed opacity while preserving stale labels and freshness windows; all nine measured pairs now pass (minimum5.555:1), with code-body equality. Two remaining legacy nested editors were migrated to named inline groups; actual composed parent paths preserve clone/Cancel/Save/address selection and return focus. Measured expanded-dialog chrome defects were repaired only by existing Bootstrap modal-dialog-scrollable modifiers. No new global palette, animation, trap or domain abstraction was created.

Retained bounded finding

P2 — Vendored Monaco word-highlighter cancellation during rapid model retirement. Location: vendored editor.api-CalNCsUg.js, exact stack/reproduction in ../ot13-script-edit/browser-cancellation-probe.json and that checkpoint README. Two accepted retarget scenes emit the narrowly classified Canceled page error; all six functional scenes/72 assertions pass, and four have zero page errors. The error does not represent changed persisted text, failed database writes or replayed callbacks. The coordinator explicitly accepted this runtime limitation. No blanket suppression, vendor patch, feature disabling or unrelated dependency upgrade was applied. If an upstream editor update is separately scoped, use $impeccable harden against this exact disposal reproduction, then $impeccable polish last; no additional repair is claimed here.

Remaining verified issue counts: P0=0, P1=0, P2=1 (the bounded vendored cancellation), P3=0. No unresolved P0/P1 was observed in the verified scope. This does not assert no issue exists outside the recorded states/platforms. Shared package rollout/name-length/older-backend limitations remain in the final acceptance report.

Final polish

Polish preserved the incumbent design: header/table grammar, wrapped technical identifiers, semantic status meanings, disclosure hierarchy, native focus and motion-final states. Desktop/phone/actual zoom captures and interaction paths informed the narrow fixes. Deliberate compact technical typography and local horizontal data/tree regions were retained. No speculative P3 styling backlog or last-minute redesign was added. The final full project suite covers the current two-title metadata candidate; raw earlier failed TRXs and browser matrices remain alongside their corrections.