{ "issue": "lmxopcua#880", "dateUtc": "2026-11-12", "baseline": "83ed880e (SDK 1.5.378.182), host/ and Client.Shared/ published Release from an untouched worktree", "candidate": { "fixed": "the #880 fix and matrix cases as a working tree on da948e5f (source-info records da948e5f); the same content landed on master as be28aa44 + 2ad72130 after a rebase onto 3fff439b", "mutation": "19930411 (pre-rebase commit of that content) with OpcUaUserIdentityFactory.UserName reverted to new UserIdentity(username, bytes), i.e. the SDK default handler" }, "apiKey": "random per run, ApiKeySecret.Generate shape, 65 chars; never recorded", "fixed": [ { "leg": "baseline-client-to-baseline-server", "status": "passed", "cases": 13, "passed": 13, "failed": [], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "1.5.378.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected" }, { "leg": "baseline-client-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 13, "passed": 10, "failed": [ "raw-UNS-URI-browse", "scalar-read-write-ns-3", "typed-array-read-write-ns-3" ], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "2.0.1.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected" }, { "leg": "candidate-client-to-baseline-server", "status": "passed", "cases": 14, "passed": 14, "failed": [], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "1.5.378.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected", "sdkDefaultFormatStatus": "BadIdentityTokenInvalid" }, { "leg": "candidate-client-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 14, "passed": 11, "failed": [ "raw-UNS-URI-browse", "scalar-read-write-ns-3", "typed-array-read-write-ns-3" ], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "2.0.1.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected", "sdkDefaultFormatStatus": "Good" }, { "leg": "candidate-driver-cli-to-baseline-server", "status": "passed", "cases": 7, "passed": 7, "failed": [] }, { "leg": "candidate-driver-cli-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 7, "passed": 6, "failed": [ "driver-raw-UNS-URI-scalar-and-array-read" ] } ], "mutation": [ { "leg": "baseline-client-to-baseline-server", "status": "passed", "cases": 13, "passed": 13, "failed": [], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "1.5.378.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected" }, { "leg": "baseline-client-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 13, "passed": 10, "failed": [ "raw-UNS-URI-browse", "scalar-read-write-ns-3", "typed-array-read-write-ns-3" ], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "2.0.1.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected" }, { "leg": "candidate-client-to-baseline-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 3, "passed": 1, "failed": [ "trusted-SignAndEncrypt-API-key", "production-length-API-key-wrong-secret-reaches-key-check" ], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "1.5.378.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenInvalid", "sdkDefaultFormatStatus": "BadIdentityTokenInvalid" }, { "leg": "candidate-client-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 14, "passed": 11, "failed": [ "raw-UNS-URI-browse", "scalar-read-write-ns-3", "typed-array-read-write-ns-3" ], "apiKeyLength": 65, "serverSdk": "2.0.1.0", "wrongSecretStatus": "BadIdentityTokenRejected", "sdkDefaultFormatStatus": "Good" }, { "leg": "candidate-driver-cli-to-baseline-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 7, "passed": 0, "failed": [ "driver-trusted-encrypted-API-key-connect", "driver-raw-UNS-URI-scalar-and-array-read", "driver-scalar-array-write-roundtrip", "driver-monitor-quality-timestamps", "production-CLI-read", "production-CLI-raw-history", "production-CLI-event-history" ] }, { "leg": "candidate-driver-cli-to-candidate-server", "status": "failed", "cases": 7, "passed": 6, "failed": [ "driver-raw-UNS-URI-scalar-and-array-read" ] } ], "readout": [ "Fixed: every SDK 2 client (Shared, driver, CLI) logs in to the SDK 1.5 server with the 65-char key; a wrong 65-char key reaches the key check (BadIdentityTokenRejected); the SDK default handler control is refused BadIdentityTokenInvalid by 1.5 and admitted by SDK 2.", "Mutation: the SDK 2 Shared connect, the wrong-key case (BadIdentityTokenInvalid instead of Rejected), the driver connect and all three CLI calls fail against the SDK 1.5 server exactly as #880 reports; the SDK 2 server legs are unaffected.", "Both runs: the UNS cases (raw-UNS-URI-browse, scalar/typed-array ns-3, driver UNS read) fail against the master server for every client SDK; a fixture gap since #808 (lmxopcua#888), not #880." ] }