Standardize role string VALUES on the canonical vocabulary
(Administrator/Designer/Deployer/Viewer; Operator/Engineer unused here):
Admin -> Administrator
Design -> Designer
Deployment -> Deployer
Audit -> Administrator (COLLAPSE; accepted privilege escalation)
AuditReadOnly-> Viewer (COLLAPSE; keeps audit-read, no export)
SoD: OperationalAuditRoles = { Administrator, Viewer },
AuditExportRoles = { Administrator }
so Viewer reads the audit log + nav but cannot bulk-export, while
Administrator does both + holds the full admin surface (the documented,
accepted auditor/admin SoD collapse).
Atomic move across every enforcement site:
- Roles constants; AuthorizationPolicies (RequireClaim values + SoD arrays +
honest XML-doc); RoleMapper Deployer check.
- ManagementActor.GetRequiredRole switch + the hard-coded site-scope
admin-bypass (now Roles.Administrator at all 6 sites). Site-scoping logic
is otherwise unchanged.
- DebugStreamHub Administrator/Deployer gates (Deployer kept case-sensitive).
- CentralUI BrowseService/BindingTester Designer guards; LdapMappingForm
dropdown now offers canonical values (incl. Viewer).
- Config-DB seed (LdapGroupMappings Id 1-4) + EF migration CanonicalizeRoles:
Id-keyed UpdateData for seed rows + idempotent raw catch-all UPDATEs for
operator-added rows. Down is lossy on the collapse (documented in-file).
No pending model changes.
Tests reworked to the collapsed model across Security/CentralUI/
ManagementService/ConfigurationDatabase/Integration suites, incl. explicit
Viewer-reads-not-exports and former-Audit-now-Administrator-escalation cases.
CHANGELOG: BREAKING security note documenting the canonicalization + SoD
collapse.
5.6 KiB
Changelog
All notable changes to ScadaBridge are documented in this file.
The format is based on Keep a Changelog.
[Unreleased]
Changed — BREAKING: canonical role names + audit separation-of-duties collapse (Task 1.7)
Role string VALUES are standardized onto the canonical vocabulary
(Administrator/Designer/Deployer/Viewer; Operator/Engineer are unused
by ScadaBridge). The legacy ScadaBridge role names were renamed and two were
collapsed:
| Legacy role | Canonical role | Notes |
|---|---|---|
Admin |
Administrator |
rename |
Design |
Designer |
rename |
Deployment |
Deployer |
rename |
Audit |
Administrator |
COLLAPSE |
AuditReadOnly |
Viewer |
COLLAPSE |
- SECURITY — privilege escalation (accepted). The former
Auditrole collapses intoAdministrator. This is a real escalation: a former audit-only user now holds the entire admin surface (create/update/delete sites, manage LDAP group→role mappings and API keys, preview/import transport bundles), not just audit read+export. This loss of auditor/admin separation-of-duties is a deliberate, accepted trade-off of the canonicalization. - SECURITY — half-SoD preserved. The former
AuditReadOnlyrole collapses intoViewer, which keeps audit READ (Audit Log page, Configuration Audit Log page, audit nav group) but cannot bulk-export. The audit policy sets are nowOperationalAuditRoles = { Administrator, Viewer }andAuditExportRoles = { Administrator }, so aViewerreads the audit log but the Export-CSV button //api/audit/exportendpoint correctly refuses it. - Enforcement. Every enforcement site moved together: the role-claim values,
the authorization policies (
RequireAdmin/RequireDesign/RequireDeploymentpolicy names are unchanged; only the role values inside them changed), theManagementActor.GetRequiredRoleswitch, the hard-coded site-scope admin-bypass (Roles.Administratoreverywhere), theDebugStreamHubAdministrator/Deployer gates, and the CentralUIBrowseService/BindingTesterDesigner guards. Site-scoping logic is otherwise unchanged — only the admin-bypass value moved from"Admin"toRoles.Administrator. - Config-DB migration
CanonicalizeRoles. Updates the four seededLdapGroupMappingsrows (Id 1-4) to the canonical role values and adds raw idempotent catch-allUPDATEs for operator-added rows (Admin/Audit→Administrator,Design→Designer,Deployment→Deployer,AuditReadOnly→Viewer). The Down migration is lossy for the collapse: it best-effort mapsAdministrator→AdminandViewer→AuditReadOnlybut cannot recover the originalAudit/AdminorViewer/AuditReadOnlydistinction. - Operator action. Any LDAP group→role mappings created with the legacy role
strings are migrated automatically by
CanonicalizeRoles. New mappings created via the CentralUI LDAP-mappings form now offer the canonical role values (including aVieweroption for audit-read-only delegation).
Changed — BREAKING: inbound API authentication
Inbound API authentication has migrated off the SQL Server X-API-Key scheme and
onto the shared ZB.MOM.WW.Auth.ApiKeys library.
- Credential format. The inbound
POST /api/{methodName}endpoint now authenticates anAuthorization: Bearer sbk_<keyId>_<secret>token instead of the rawX-API-Key: <key>header. The secret is verified with a peppered, constant-time HMAC compare inside the shared library verifier. - Storage. Inbound API keys now live in the shared
ZB.MOM.WW.Auth.ApiKeysSQLite store, not the SQL Server configuration database. The deterministic-HMACApiKeytable is gone. - Authorization model. A key's allowed methods are now its per-key scopes
(scope string == method name, ordinal/case-sensitive). The previous
ApiMethod.ApprovedApiKeyIdsCSV that linked methods to key IDs has been removed. - Peppering. Keys are peppered per environment via
ScadaBridge:InboundApi:ApiKeyPepper(≥ 16 characters, different per environment, kept secret). The same configuration key now backs the library verifier's pepper secret.
BREAKING — all existing inbound API keys are INVALIDATED and must be re-issued. Old
X-API-Keycredentials and their stored HMAC hashes are not migrated and are not recoverable; theApiKeystable is dropped. Operators must re-issue every inbound key as ansbk_…token and update every API client. See the runbook:docs/operations/inbound-api-key-reissue.md.
Removed
- The SQL Server
ApiKeyentity (ZB.MOM.WW.ScadaBridge.Commons.Entities.InboundApi.ApiKey), its EF Core mapping, and itsIInboundApiRepositorykey methods (GetApiKeyByIdAsync,GetAllApiKeysAsync,GetApiKeyByValueAsync,AddApiKeyAsync,UpdateApiKeyAsync,DeleteApiKeyAsync,GetApprovedKeysForMethodAsync). - The
ApiMethod.ApprovedApiKeyIdsproperty, its EF mapping, and the CSV parse/serialize helpers. - The legacy hashing code:
ApiKeyHasher/IApiKeyHasherand the in-repo inboundApiKeyValidator(superseded by the sharedIApiKeyVerifier), plus their DI registrations and tests.
Migrations
RetireInboundApiKeyStore— drops theApiKeystable and theApiMethods.ApprovedApiKeyIdscolumn.Downrecreates both, but dropped keys are not recoverable: rolling the migration back does not restore credentials. Rollback means reverting the deployment, then re-issuing keys.