ROW 80 (observability correctness). An unreplicated site published
LocalDbReplicationConnected=false / LocalDbOplogBacklog=0, contradicting the
nullable semantics every doc and the proto already state ("null means no
reading, NOT disconnected with an empty backlog").
Root cause: the replication engine is registered unconditionally and idles
without a peer, so ISyncStatus answers false/0 on a node that was never meant to
replicate, and LocalDbReplicationStatusReporter passed that straight through.
Two consequences: an operator read connected:false on a healthy site as a fault,
and central's null branches — row 33's conditional KPI emission and
sustained-badge anchor exclusion — never received the null they exist for, so
rig site-b/site-c emitted a permanently misleading
localDbReplicationConnected=0 series.
Fix mirrors the SiteEventLogReplicationCheck precedent: the Host evaluates
SiteLocalDbSetup.ReplicationIsConfigured ONCE and passes it to
AddLocalDbReplicationHealthBridge as a third provider; unconfigured
short-circuits the probe to (null, null). HealthMonitoring never reads LocalDb
config itself, and the same captured value now also feeds
SiteEventLogReplicationCheck so the two surfaces cannot disagree.
ISiteHealthCollector.SetLocalDbReplicationStatus widens to bool? — the
non-nullable bool was the type-level root cause (null was inexpressible).
false now means exactly one thing: configured, peer session down = a real fault.
Wire/central/UI needed no change: the proto already carries BoolValue/Int64Value
wrappers and the aggregator + KPI source already branch on null. This makes code
match doc, so no doc claim was weakened.
Watch the trap that caused this: configured-ness is PeerAddress OR ApiKey (only
the dialling half sets a peer address). The pre-existing SiteLocalDbWiringTests
fixture sets ApiKey and IS a replicating node, so its false/0 assertion is
correct and is kept, with a comment saying so; the new
UnreplicatedSiteLocalDbHealthTests fixture is the genuinely-unreplicated one.
ROW 73 (silent loss of self-heal). AkkaHostedService skips
SiteReconciliationActor when no IDeploymentConfigFetcher is resolvable, and that
skip was a lone boot Warning — a node with no self-heal path at all went on
reporting itself perfectly healthy forever.
Adds tri-state SiteHealthReport.StartupReconcilerActive (null = not reported,
i.e. the central self-report or a pre-row-73 site build; true = running;
false = booted without it), latched once at boot by the Host in both branches.
Additive proto field 29 (BoolValue, vendored C# regenerated via
docker/regen-proto.sh centralcontrol; csproj restored, verified empty diff).
The skip branch also raises its log to Error — no configuration makes the
fetcher legitimately absent on a site node — and writes a best-effort
deployment/Error site event so the evidence outlives the boot log.
Central treatment: a "No self-heal" WARNING badge on the site tile, not a
failure. Config still reaches the node via LocalDb replication while it is up;
what it lost is recovery from a deploy that landed while it was down — degraded,
not offline. Only the explicit false is badged (badging null would light up the
whole fleet the moment central is upgraded ahead of the sites), and offline
sites are skipped, matching the replication-backlog badge.
Fail-before evidence: with the row-80 gate behaviourally reverted,
UnreplicatedSite_HealthReport_ReportsNullForBothLocalDbFields fails
"Expected: null / Actual: False" and 3 of the 8 new reporter unit tests fail.
Tests: HealthMonitoring 128, Host 518, CentralUI 1051, Communication 717,
Commons 715, SiteEventLogging 81 — all green.
LocalDbOplogBacklog was reported and Prometheus-exported with nothing consuming
it: not sampled into KPI history, so a purge-burst spike could not be reviewed
after the fact, and no threshold treatment anywhere. Both halves shipped.
KPI SAMPLING. SiteHealthKpiSampleSource now emits localDbOplogBacklog and
localDbReplicationConnected (0/1), and the backlog is charted on the Health
dashboard's per-site trend panel. Charting is the point: a point-in-time tile
can never answer 'did that spike drain?', which is the only thing separating an
expected purge burst from a stalled peer.
Both are CONDITIONALLY emitted rather than coerced with ?? 0 like the
auditBacklogPending metric beside them. Both health-report fields are nullable
and null means 'no reading' — replication not configured (rig site-b/site-c) or
a failed poll — never zero. A fabricated 0 would render a pair that cannot read
its own oplog, or one deliberately unreplicated, as perfectly healthy once a
minute forever, burying the real series. So a site emits 12 metrics when
unreplicated and 14 when replicated, and a GAP in these two series truthfully
means 'not replicated / not reporting'. Note false and null differ for the
connected flag: a configured link that is DOWN samples as 0; no link samples as
nothing. Both fold as Gauge (summing an oplog depth, or a 0/1 flag, per hour is
meaningless).
THRESHOLD SEMANTICS — sustained, not instantaneous. This is the design, not a
refinement. The site_events retention purge is CDC-captured like any other
write, so the backlog jumps by the deleted batch and drains as the peer acks
it; a bare 'backlog > threshold' badge would fire on every replicated site
every day and be ignored within a week. Healthy is defined by the backlog
RETURNING to ~0, which only a dwell can express. CentralHealthAggregator holds
LocalDbBacklogAboveSince — the instant the backlog first rose above
LocalDbBacklogThreshold (default 1000) — and the badge appears only after
LocalDbBacklogSustainedFor (default 15 min). A report at or below the threshold
clears the anchor; one above leaves the ORIGINAL instant intact, so the window
is sustained rather than sliding.
The null case is deliberately a third branch: a null backlog leaves the anchor
UNCHANGED rather than clearing it. Null is evidence neither of a drain nor of a
backlog, so a node going blind mid-climb must not silently reset its own dwell,
and an unreplicated site (null forever) never accumulates an anchor and can
never be badged.
Validation rejects a non-positive threshold (0 would badge every replicated site
permanently, since an idle backlog already sits at it) and a dwell shorter than
one ReportInterval (satisfiable by a single sample, which collapses the check
back into the bare threshold it replaces).
DOC CORRECTION worth flagging: this row's premise was 'mirror the SiteAuditBacklog
configurable threshold badge'. That badge does not exist — Component-HealthMonitoring.md
described it in two places but no option, no comparison and no markup were ever
implemented. The two stale claims are corrected here rather than left to send the
next reader looking for it; the LocalDb badge is built fresh on the Metrics-stale
badge's pattern, which is a real configurable-threshold badge.
Tests: HealthMonitoring 115 (9 new aggregator tests incl. purge-burst-drains,
unreplicated-never-anchors, null-mid-climb, exact-threshold, stale-report; 5 new
validator tests; 4 new sampler tests incl. the null-semantics and false-vs-null
cases); CentralUI 1042 (5 new badge/chart tests incl. the purge-burst negative
control); Commons Kpi 93; KpiHistory 54.
Tasks 5 and 6 of the Phase 2 plan, committed together because their test
fallout is entangled — several fixtures construct both stores.
StoreAndForwardStorage and SiteStorageService now take ILocalDb. Connections
come from ILocalDb.CreateConnection(), which hands out an already-open,
pragma-configured connection carrying the zb_hlc_next() UDF the capture triggers
call; a raw connection would lack the UDF and every write to a replicated table
would fail closed. Deleted with the connection strings: S&F's
EnsureDatabaseDirectoryExists and its per-open busy_timeout pragma, and the site
service's BusyTimeoutFloorSeconds normalization — LocalDb owns all of it now.
DI: AddSiteRuntime's string overload is gone (nothing left to supply), so the
Host calls the no-arg form. ScadaBridge:Database:SiteDbPath and
StoreAndForwardOptions.SqliteDbPath survive only as the migrator's source
locations in Tasks 8/9.
Two things the plan did not anticipate, both worth reading:
1. FOUND A REAL LATENT DEFECT, from Phase 1, now fixed. The plan assumed
directory creation simply moved to LocalDb along with file ownership. It did
not: the LocalDb library never creates the parent directory, and
SqliteLocalDb opens the file eagerly in its constructor — so a missing
directory is a hard boot failure ("SQLite Error 14: unable to open database
file"), not a degraded start. The default site config points at the RELATIVE
path ./data/site-localdb.db, so any site node without a pre-existing data/
directory fails to boot. The docker rig escapes only because its volume mount
happens to create /app/data — a coincidence that would have hidden this until
a bare-metal or fresh deployment. This has been latent since Phase 1 made
LocalDb:Path required; deleting S&F's EnsureDatabaseDirectoryExists here
would have widened it. Re-established the guarantee at the layer that now
owns the path (SiteLocalDbDirectory.Ensure, called before AddZbLocalDb) and
pinned it with SiteLocalDbDirectoryTests. Non-vacuity is not assumed: two
tests written against the wrong assumption failed with exactly this
SQLite Error 14 before the fix existed.
2. Test fallout was ~7x the plan's estimate. The plan named "fixtures" in one
project; the constructor change actually reaches 40 files across 7 test
projects, and most used Mode=Memory;Cache=Shared — which LocalDb has no
equivalent for, so every one had to move to a real temp file. Rather than
copy the Phase 1 TestLocalDb fixture into 7 projects, added a shared
tests/ZB.MOM.WW.ScadaBridge.TestSupport library (not a test project) so the
WAL-sidecar cleanup and the "real, not stubbed" rationale live in one place.
Retargeted rather than deleted, in both directions: the S&F WAL test now asserts
against the LocalDb-backed store (WAL genuinely is LocalDb's job), while the
directory-creation test moved to Host.Tests (that guarantee is NOT LocalDb's).
SiteStorageServiceTests.Initialize_EnablesWalJournalMode got the same treatment.
DeploymentManagerMediumFindingsTests induced a persistence failure via an
unopenable path, which no longer reaches the assertion since the fixture now
throws first; it induces the same failure shape via an uninitialized store.
Verified: full solution build 0 warnings; SiteRuntime 532, Host 318,
AuditLog 355, ExternalSystemGateway 142, HealthMonitoring 97,
StoreAndForward 153 — 1597 passed, 0 failed.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BL2Vu1ESDQ9SCN4gVKkdts
The NuGetAuditSuppress in Directory.Packages.props was masking a LIVE high-severity
vulnerability, not documenting an accepted one. Only the Host project resolved a
patched SQLitePCLRaw.lib.e_sqlite3 2.1.12 (transitively, via ZB.MOM.WW.Auth.ApiKeys).
Every other SQLite consumer - AuditLog, SiteRuntime, StoreAndForward, SiteEventLogging
and 11 test projects - still resolved the vulnerable 2.1.11.
The suppression's rationale was factually wrong: it claimed 'the only patched native
lib is the SQLitePCLRaw 3.x line'. 2.1.12 patches this advisory within the 2.1.x line,
so the feared risky force-override of the whole family to 3.x is unnecessary.
Fix: explicit PackageReference to the patched 2.1.12 in each SQLite-consuming project,
plus the central PackageVersion row. Suppression removed, so the advisory is audited
again rather than silenced.
Rejected alternative: CentralPackageTransitivePinningEnabled. It clears the advisory in
one line but makes every central version a ceiling for transitive resolution, demanding
bumps to Google.Protobuf, Grpc.Net.Client, Microsoft.Data.SqlClient and Newtonsoft.Json.
That is a gRPC/data-access change to a production SCADA platform and deserves its own
reviewed commit.
Verified: forced full-solution restore reports no NU1903 (only the pre-existing,
unrelated AngleSharp NU1902 in CentralUI.Tests); all four previously-vulnerable src
projects now resolve 2.1.12; 55 projects build 0 warnings / 0 errors; 1108 tests pass
across the SQLite layer (AuditLog 354, ConfigurationDatabase 357, Security 181,
StoreAndForward 152, SiteEventLogging 64).
The host does not guarantee IHostedService.StopAsync is driven before the DI
container is disposed — WebApplicationFactory's teardown reaches Dispose first
— so cancelling the internal CTS from StopAsync threw ObjectDisposedException
and aborted the host's whole shutdown sequence. Four services shared the same
copy-pasted lifecycle and the same two races: StopAsync cancelling an already-
disposed CTS, and StartAsync reading _cts.Token lazily inside the Task.Run
lambda, which faults the loop task the host awaits when Dispose wins that race.
Each service now captures the token on the caller's thread, tolerates a
disposed CTS, and cancels-before-disposing so the loop is always signalled and
its pending Task.Delay sees a cancelled token rather than a dead source.
SiteAuditBacklogReporter also gains the outer OperationCanceledException guard
its sibling SiteAuditRetentionService already carried (arch-review 04 R2, R7),
without which a shutdown landing mid-probe threw TaskCanceledException out of
Host.StopAsync.
Surfaced while verifying the Gitea #15 test-harness fix: in Host.Tests the
aborted teardown skipped the fixture's env-var restore, contaminating every
later test in the run.
Refs: Gitea #15
AddSiteEventLogHealthMetricsBridge registered via AddHostedService(factory-lambda),
which sets ImplementationFactory and leaves ImplementationType null. The prior
ImplementationType == guard was therefore silently dead — a second call would spin
up a second SiteEventLogFailureCountReporter. Fix: add a private
SiteEventLogHealthMetricsBridgeMarker singleton and guard on its ServiceType instead.
Also corrects the cycle-path comment in both ServiceCollectionExtensions.cs and
SiteEventLogFailureCountReporter.cs: StoreAndForward.csproj does reference
SiteEventLogging.csproj, so the transitive path HealthMonitoring → StoreAndForward →
SiteEventLogging is real, but adding a direct HealthMonitoring → SiteEventLogging
reference would NOT create a cycle (SiteEventLogging has no back-edge to HealthMonitoring).
The Func<long> seam is a coupling-avoidance measure, not a cycle-breaker.
Adds AddSiteEventLogHealthMetricsBridgeTests.AddSiteEventLogHealthMetricsBridge_IsIdempotent_DoesNotDoubleRegister_HostedService
as a regression test (builds provider and asserts exactly one reporter via GetServices<IHostedService>().OfType<T>()).
Perf re-baseline (HotPathLatencyTests): empirical p95 on Apple M-series Release
build: 4KB DetailsJson slow path ≈14 µs, small-DetailsJson no-redactors ≈2 µs,
true no-op fast path ≈0 µs. Thresholds updated: 200 µs / 30 µs / 5 µs (≈15×
headroom for contested CI runners). Old thresholds (50 µs / 10 µs) were set for
the pre-C3 typed-field path; canonical JSON parse+rewrite is empirically faster.
Adds a third test (Filter_Apply_NoDetailsJson_FastPath) that asserts same-instance
return on the DetailsJson-null + within-cap fast path. Env-var overrides retained.
CollapseAuditLogToCanonicalMigrationTests (new): three MSSQL-gated [SkippableFact]
tests verifying Action/Category/Outcome projection, NULL Actor, DetailsJson codec
round-trip, and all six persisted computed columns (Kind/Status/SourceSiteId/
ExecutionId/ParentExecutionId) for ApiOutbound, InboundAuthFailure, and Failed-
status rows.
AddAuditLogTableMigrationTests: rename CreatesFiveNamedIndexes →
CreatesNineNamedIndexes; expand coverage from 5 original indexes to all 9 named
non-clustered indexes present after CollapseAuditLogToCanonical (adds
IX_AuditLog_Execution, IX_AuditLog_ParentExecution, IX_AuditLog_Node_Occurred,
UX_AuditLog_EventId).
Dead-cref cleanup: zero references to the deleted IAuditPayloadFilter /
DefaultAuditPayloadFilter / SafeDefaultAuditPayloadFilter types remain in any
.cs file (source or test). 26 occurrences across 13 files replaced with correct
references to IAuditRedactor / ScadaBridgeAuditRedactor / SafeDefaultAuditRedactor
or reworded as plain prose.
Residual sweep: no unused transitional code found beyond the acknowledged
"C3 transitional shim" comments on IngestedAtUtc stamping (active code, not dead).
Joseph Doherty